From the start, the channel has pushed its producers for a gender-balanced panel. Except it isn’t easy. Most company bosses, and even more so in tech, are men. The more money and power there is, the fewer women there are. So less choice.
The first season had 2 women out of 6, thanks to Delphine André (the Charles André group, which she inherited from her father) and Catherine Barba (adviser and business angel in a dozen companies, including Leetchi). André stayed on until season 3. In season 2, which saw the arrival of Anthony Bourbon and Jean-Pierre Nadir (both seasons 2 to 6), she was joined by Sophie Mechaly (of the fashion label Paul&Joe) and Isabelle Weill. This unknown to the general public (and to pretty much everyone else) was pushed on Arthur by Alain Weill, the media boss, her ex-husband6. The result was a disaster.
First because she had never really invested: she had mainly been on the management of NextGroupTV (run by her husband) and chair of the RMC-BFM foundation. And second because, on set, it just didn’t work. One person who attended the filming talks of cringeworthy scenes, and of a panellist unable to hold her own. According to another source, who confirms this account, the editing was a struggle. A panellist who worked alongside her thinks it all has more to do with settling scores.
She was replaced by Isabelle Chevalier (Bio-K+, season 3), who in turn made way for Stéphanie Delestre (QAPA, season 4) and above all Kelly Massol (the haircare brand Les Secrets de Loly, seasons 4 to 6), who has since become one of the faces of the show. In the meantime she was joined by Alice Lhabouz (the asset manager Trecento AM, seasons 5 and 6), said to be close to Arthur. Something it has not been possible to confirm.
Gender balance explains some of the hiring. But it says nothing about how legitimate the profiles are. And on that front, the gaps are real.