An exclusive experience that reinvents office property at La Défense, Paris's business district: that is the promise of the sales pitch.
The promise has been online since this spring1. It is selling the top 6 floors of Cœur Défense, from the 34th to the 39th, renamed The Penthouse for the occasion, with loggias for working, as the pitch puts it, between sky and city2. On LinkedIn, the manager tells the story of the works with the pride of a heroic feat: 76 tonnes of concrete broken up and removed from an occupied building, a façade redesigned more than 125 metres above the ground. You can picture the meeting from here, the one where the marketing guys pulled out their finest adjectives on pretty slides.
A local broker who wishes to remain anonymous is less lyrical. The complex is 25 years old, but it is apparently already ageing badly and no longer matches what big tenants demand. Hence the concrete being broken up at the top. And the vacancy that drags on and piles up.
The site has a history. This is where the Esso tower once stood, delivered in 1963 to bring together the oil company's 1,550 French employees: one of the first self-service canteens in the country, a cinema in the basement, an air-conditioned room for the IBM computers3. 30 years later, it became the first tower ever demolished at La Défense, judged unsuited to companies' needs. On this concourse, buildings die young.
In its place, Unibail raised Cœur Défense, designed by Jean-Paul Viguier and delivered in 2001: 2 twin towers of 160 metres joined by a glass atrium, nearly 160,000 m² of offices, the largest office complex in Europe4. In July 2007, at the exact top of the cycle, the American bank Lehman Brothers bought the lot for €2.1bn. A French record for a single asset, paid, according to the press, 21% above the valuation of December 2006.
Everything was signed the same summer. The buying company is called Heart of La Défense (in French), HOLD to its friends, owned by a Luxembourg holding company, Dame Luxembourg. To pay, it borrowed €1.6bn from Lehman Brothers Bankhaus, secured by a mortgage on the building5. Present and future rents were assigned to the lender. The cherry on the cheesecake: Dame Luxembourg pledged all of HOLD's shares with a forfeiture clause, which lets the lender take them over without going before a judge. The loans were at floating rates, so hedged against rising rates. And the provider of the hedge was, again, Lehman. The bank was on both sides of the counter: it bought the building and sold itself the loan and the hedge. What could possibly go wrong?
Probably nothing. Except that 14 months later, the bank no longer existed. September 2008: Lehman collapsed. The hedge was worthless, it had to be replaced in a hurry on a dead market, and without a replacement the lender could demand everything, right away. On 3 November 2008, the Paris commercial court opened safeguard proceedings for HOLD and Dame Luxembourg.
The creditors fought back: the building was full, the rents were coming in, the safeguard was just a manoeuvre to escape the contracts. The white-collar brawl went all the way to the Cour de cassation, France's highest court, which ruled on 8 March 2011: whatever the motive, a company that can show insurmountable difficulties is entitled to its safeguard5. A landmark ruling, published with full honours, recited ever since in law school lecture halls. The Versailles appeal court, on referral, would confirm the opening of both safeguards on 19 January 20126.
Getting out of court would take another 3 years. In the spring of 2014, the Texan fund Lone Star picked up the whole thing for around €1.3bn, after buying a large chunk of the case's debt, which always helps in a negotiation. Its press release promised to polish up the tower's image and improve an occupancy rate it called perfectible7. Perfectible. Translation: there were empty floors.
Filings of Heart of La Défense, meeting of 30 September 2017: the seller's claims, €295M, converted into capital a month before the sale.
3 and a half years later, on 30 October 2017, Lone Star, through its Luxembourg holding company LSREF 3 Lagoon, sold 100% of HOLD's shares to a French trio: Amundi Immobilier, Crédit Agricole Assurances and the aforementioned Primonial REIM4. €1.8bn for the building, €500M more than the price paid in court8. Except that this x1.8 mixes up two things. For 100% of HOLD's shares, the buyers actually put down a little over €900M9: the rest is debt, which doesn't leave with the seller but stays in the company, attached to the building and its rents. 13 advisers around the table, investment banks, lawyers, notaries, tax specialists and auditors included10. On the buyers' side, the chairman of Primonial REIM's management board, Laurent Fléchet, hailed the deal:
An emblematic transaction, he said, because of its size, its location and the quality of its design.
Laurent Fléchet, chairman of the management board of Primonial REIM, 30 October 2017
Amundi, for its part, claimed the biggest acquisition on the French market that year. Do the maths, for the building: €2.1bn in 2007, €1.3bn in court in 2014, €1.8bn in 2017. In this story, only one owner made money. The one who bought in court.
Cœur Défense: the price of the building, at each sale
Building values reported by the press, rounded. The 2017 split between shares and debt is taken from the filings of Heart of La Défense.
Defense-92.fr, Batiweb, Crédit Agricole press release; filings of Heart of La Défense at the registry of the Paris commercial court.
Filings of Heart of La Défense, 2017: the eight funds of the three buyers, line by line.