💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 01

Small fry, big mysteries

Not everything is political, but politics takes an interest in everything: so goes a line attributed to Machiavelli.

Well, I think he’s wrong, Machiavelli. Politics comes from the Greek πολιτικός (politikos), meaning “citizen”. Historically, it was what was called the life of the city. Today the very word politics has become a turn-off, because it conjures up the image we have of the speakers on TV: old, white, in suits. Sure, over the past 20 years, the caricature has shifted a little. But the public’s image of it, not so much.

This rejection peaked during the famous Yellow Vests period, the French protest movement. The movement was always very mixed, and even today it’s hard to define, so different was it between the first days and the weeks that followed on the roundabouts. But it was strongly marked by a rejection of the political as such. So much so that neither the parties nor the unions knew how to deal with it.

Then the word apolitical appeared. And yet what could be more political than the Yellow Vests, who wanted, in turn, to change the Constitution, recall elected officials, change the tax system or demand more benefits?

You could also mention Emmanuel Macron who, last summer, explained that the Olympics were not political. Then why does choosing a host city lead to endless diplomatic horse-trading? Why are some nations shunned, or on the contrary protected? Banning Russian athletes, or giving Palestinian athletes a status, is highly political, whatever you think about the issue.

If I’m giving you this (long) introduction, it’s because it probably helps explain a very strange paradox which, according to a seasoned observer of political life, only dates back a few decades. Though, honestly, I couldn’t be bothered to spend hours cross-checking that, since it’s not (entirely) the topic.

At the last local elections, whose bizarre second round, you’ll remember, took place in the middle of lockdown, the 42 cities with more than 100,000 inhabitants were all won by the candidate of a national party, with the notable exception of three cities:

  • Le Havre, with Édouard Philippe, the former prime minister, classed as miscellaneous right, formerly of LR, the traditional right-wing party (and formerly of the Socialist Party, the PS, as it happens), who has his own party, Horizons, but one without a big enough share of the vote to be counted separately1;
  • Annecy, with François Astorg, classed as green, formerly of EELV, the French Greens;
  • Saint-Paul, on the French Indian Ocean island of Réunion, with Huguette Bello, classed as Pour La Réunion, a local party, even if in the National Assembly it sits with the left-wing alliances NUPES and then NFP, and which grew out of the PCR, the Réunion Communist Party.

But in smaller towns, mayors readily keep their distance from parties, probably because, even if they share the ideas of one side or the other, they prefer their constituents to see them as independent. And the proportion is staggering:

  • 13.71% miscellaneous right;
  • 13.16% miscellaneous left;
  • 5.77% miscellaneous centre;
  • 6% miscellaneous nothing;
  • 55.30% no label at all.

Even more staggering is the gap between the parties you hear about every day in the media and their results in local elections.

I started with these figures because they put into perspective the funding of the 534 (!) or so political parties registered in France. Because while everyone knows Mélenchon’s, Macron’s or Le Pen’s, and you sometimes hear about the micro-parties of Le Maire or Ciotti (rarely for good reasons, by the way), there are loads of others, most of them regional, departmental or even municipal in scope.

And that has a huge impact on funding.