💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

Show me the money

To keep it simple, there are 4 ways for a party to make money:

  • Public funding, mainly based on election results;
  • Membership fees from individuals (or elected officials);
  • Elected officials handing back part of their allowances;
  • Private donations, from individuals or companies.

But in reality, all 4 are public money, since donations qualify for a 66% tax reduction, up to 20% of taxable income.

Note: thanks to the CNCCFP2, the French watchdog for campaign and party finances, for its help with the figures

Membership fees

In 2023, €44M was spent on membership fees by individuals, giving the right to a 66% tax reduction, i.e. up to €29M in cost to the state. On its own, the PCF, the French Communist Party, claims 13% of all donations, way ahead of its little pals.

These figures3 put the real number of members into perspective, sometimes a long way from the numbers claimed. For example, LFI, Mélenchon’s hard-left party, which claims 370K members, received precisely… €0 in fees. The figures for the Modem, a centrist party (12K members claimed), show €9 per person, when membership costs €20. That’s closer to 5,150 members. Same for Horizons: the €30 membership works out at 7,830 members (instead of 34,000). Or Debout la France, a small Eurosceptic right-wing party, which with its €35 membership tops out at 2,500 members (not 15,632).

Ah well, must be inflation.

The figures look more consistent on the far right, with amounts between €20 and €40 for Reconquête, the UPR, the RN (Le Pen’s National Rally) or Les Patriotes. Same for LR or Renaissance, Macron’s party, when you move a little less to the right.

The same figures look much less consistent on the left… but not for the reasons you might imagine. With €94 per member at the NPA, the New Anticapitalist Party, €144 at the PCF and even €179 at Lutte Ouvrière, a Trotskyist party, and since you can assume parties don’t lie downwards about their membership, the likely explanation is that pay-what-you-want fees encourage high fees.

Total received in membership fees, by party

Fees from elected officials

Only 10 parties receive more than €100K in fees from their elected officials. Left-wing parties alone account for nearly 75% of this funding, which, when you think about it, could be compared to a sort of neo-communism. Because the principle is that elected officials give a percentage of their income (which comes from public money) to the party, to fund it. What’s surprising is that these amounts don’t seem linked to election results at all. It’s even the reverse for left-wing parties: the more elected officials they have and the better their results… the less they give back to the party.

Amounts handed back by elected officials compared with local election scores

That said, beware of Simpson’s paradox, since parliamentary election results concern a few hundred elected officials, municipal ones tens of thousands, and on top of that come the regional and departmental (county-level) elections, which are hard to study.

Still, as you can see, the left and the right clearly have very different practices.

Total received in fees from elected officials, by party

Donations

Donations show a completely different pattern. Small parties, usually local, account for 17% of the amounts, when they’re almost absent from the other sources of funding. While the PCF once again shows up at the top of the ranking, it’s more surprising to see Reconquête ! in 2nd place. Proof, probably, that the party managed to rally people massively around Zemmour, its founder, to make up for its complete lack of other funding, since at its creation it had almost no elected officials, despite a few catches from the RN. Rather surprisingly, you also see Les Patriotes, LO (Lutte Ouvrière), the small left-wing party Générations or the Syndicat de la Famille (formerly La Manif pour tous, the movement against same-sex marriage), while the big traditional parties are further back. And the PS doesn’t even make the ranking.

While this is indeed down to the very nature of these last parties, which have few or no elected officials, it could also look like parties with a strong stance, whose members are strongly committed to them ideologically.

Public funding

Finally, there’s public funding. Having looked at the other sources, which are rather tied to commitment, from individuals or elected officials, you may be surprised by these particularly undemocratic allocations. Because yes, this funding is mainly tied to national results, notably the famous 5% in the presidential election, which triggers the reimbursement of campaign expenses, but you can clearly see that, compared with what voters are willing to give and the members these parties represent, there’s a real gap.

The reality is that 10 parties alone take 92% of public funding. And fewer than 30 are funded by it at all. Above all, the whole thing looks like a huge vicious circle where, to exist, you need money, and to get money, you need to exist. Sure, Reconquête ! looks like a counter-example, and the Macronist party, born from the ashes (and thanks to the resources) of the aborted candidacy of DSK, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, had followed a fairly similar path. But for smaller political players, existing on the media and electoral stage seems genuinely hard.