When one of the best VCs in the world buys into a start-up, you can imagine how long the due diligence takes. Not just because a lot of money is involved, but above all because it sends a gigantic signal to the market.
And yet every investor seems to ignore the macroeconomic backdrop.
When the round closes1, according to Thierry Vignal, they don’t even realise that rates are rising and that it’s not the right time at all.
That €20M is bound to turn heads: the founders find themselves holding big stakes in a company valued at €100M.
For €20M, Thierry Vignal quips (lucidly), anyone would sleep with their own mother. The moment a guy offers you €20M, whatever the reasons, you say yes, he adds. And he said yes.
Because plenty of people like to say “not for all the money in the world would I do this” or “not even for €XM would I do that”, but how many have actually been in a situation where the offer was really on the table?
And yet, a few months earlier, Russia had invaded Ukraine. A situation Yuri Milner knows inside out, since he renounced his Russian citizenship, partly to escape sanctions.
Meanwhile, inflation has been exploding since 2021, and in France the consumer price index is passing 6%.
There is NO possible scenario in which rates don’t go up.
None.
Seriously.
And while a rate rise will be felt worldwide, it will hit property even harder, since it takes time to react, especially residential. A market Masteos is 100% exposed to. All the more so as inflation is already weighing very heavily on the cost of materials, and therefore of renovation works.
Which is another oddity of this round.
Masteos is valued at €100M, 10 times less than the French business neobank Shine, for instance. According to several people around at the time, the ratios were fine. Because Shine was making barely €4M in revenue, while Masteos was making €20M. But 50% of that was renovation revenue, which made it a big building contractor.
And yet, at that point, Masteos is at its peak: in June 2022 the company closes 250 deals. But breakeven (€5M/month) is more than double that. The company burns €2 in the hope of generating 1.
And here we’re facing 2 huge problems:
A point that had already been a problem in his “royalties era” for Cédric O’Neill, founder of Bricks.
Managing individual tenants is very hard, he says: you end up with a whole army of people doing everything by hand, and it eats into your returns.
A point confirmed by the manager of a residential SCPI, a French non-traded property fund.
In reality, you only need to know the tiniest bit about property and look at the business plan for 10 minutes to realise you shouldn’t invest in Masteos. Not because it’s a bad company. But because it can’t do what a VC expects from a start-up investment.
That is what led Cédric O’Neill to switch from the proptech model to the fintech one, becoming an intermediary rather than a manager.
Maxime Hanquier admits they never managed to choose between being a start-up and being an operational company. When they raised big, he says, they should have made that choice, and hired a leadership team to match.
And yet both bosses have rather start-up profiles, and delegating operations was both very much the fashion and the logic of the renovation world.
The fact remains that millions are burned on marketing to build a brand and acquire leads. Or €500K to buy software that, according to everyone interviewed, made no sense at all. Or offices (in the former mansion where the Star Academy, France’s hit TV talent show, had been filmed) at €80,000 / month.
A former employee recalls feeling that money was flowing freely and that the company wasn’t counting what it spent. Everyone was well paid, some had company cars. It was the good life.