What future can we predict for the Livret A, and for how it is used? For decades, the whole thing has rested on a fragile balance between a guarantee for savers, funding for social housing and the banks’ interests. But with savings piling up, social housing funding proving ineffective and budget tensions, reform seems inevitable. The question is which one. Roughly speaking, there are 3 main options.
❌Leave it all alone The status quo would let the banks and the State keep benefiting from a system that works (for them). The Livret A would remain attractive, liquid and poorly paid, and would keep funding social housing and local authorities. But the model is running out of steam: the profitability of the Fonds d’épargne is falling, and social housing isn’t seeing the benefits. The question will come up again eventually, but not for the people who have to decide today.
🐷Make better use of the funds Redirect dormant savings towards more productive projects, such as the energy transition or strategic infrastructure. And there’s no shortage of candidates for the money. Over the past year, using it for defence has come up several times (the kind with tanks, not the kind lawyers bill for). Limit the stock of idle money and improve the traceability of funds. The problem: that means overhauling the Fonds d’épargne, and neither the banks nor the Caisse des Dépôts want anyone shaking up their habits.
💡A rate rise or a surprise tax Raise savers’ returns to make up for inflation… to the great dismay of the Caisse des Dépôts and the banks, which would see the cost explode just when the Caisse is struggling to earn a return on all of its deposits. Partly tax the interest to limit windfall effects and claw back a slice of the pie. But that’s a bit like giving with one hand and taking back with the other. Either way, it’s a political bombshell: touching the Livret A means risking a massive backlash from savers, and nobody wants the Yellow Vest protests back.
The Cour des comptes has already sounded the alarm several times. It points to a paradox: while the Livret A soaks up hundreds of billions, its effectiveness in funding public needs is deteriorating. Its latest report, a scathing one, delivers an unequivocal verdict that sums up the points we’ve covered:
An under-used stock of savings: for lack of demand for social housing loans, the Caisse des Dépôts is left with billions lying idle, paid at a rate that doesn’t keep up with inflation.
A dependence on low rates: when rates were at rock bottom, the Fonds d’épargne could deliver acceptable profitability. Today, rising rates are seriously complicating things.
Limited transparency: part of the money kept by the banks is supposed to finance SMEs and the ecological transition… but nobody really knows whether it does.
A system that favours the better-off: despite its popular image, the Livret A mainly benefits the wealthiest savers. 30% of deposits are held by just 7% of accounts.
In other words, the money is there, but it’s badly distributed and badly used. The problem isn’t so much the product itself as the inability to make it evolve effectively. And to that end, the auditors put forward seven proposals:
Change the governance of the Fonds d’épargne The idea would be to improve the transparency and traceability of the funds collected through the Livret A. Today, the Caisse des Dépôts manages these deposits with little external oversight. Better supervision would stop the money from lying idle for nothing.
Rethink where the funding is directed Currently, the Livret A mainly funds social housing, but part of the money could be redirected to other needs: public infrastructure, the energy transition or strategic industries.
Reduce the tax breaks The Livret A is tax-free, which makes it attractive to savers… but costs the State dearly. Partly taxing the interest could claw back some of this windfall and stop it from becoming a product for rentiers.
Review the savings ceilings Today, the Livret A ceiling is €22.95K, but by combining it with other regulated accounts, some savers manage to go well beyond that. Limiting this stacking would stop the better-off from profiting excessively.
Regulate the banks’ use of the funds more strictly The banks keep part of the Livret A deposits, but how they use them lacks clarity. Tighter control would stop these funds from being diverted into investments that are more profitable for them, at the expense of their public-interest mission.
Decentralise part of the funds managed by the CDC Today, nearly 60% of Livret A deposits are managed directly by the CDC. Handing part of them over to the banks could let them respond faster when granting loans and avoid bureaucratic bottlenecks.
Rethink the funding model for social housing The main purpose of the Livret A is to fund social housing, but with rising interest rates, this funding is becoming less and less attractive. Loan terms should be reviewed to encourage landlords to make more use of them.
Nearly 3 years later, none has been acted on. Because while they seem full of common sense, putting them into practice is another story. Any reform of the Livret A touches a fragile balance between household savings, public finances and, as we’ve seen, the conflicting interests of the parties involved:
The banks dig their heels in Any change to how the funds are split or paid directly hits their margins. So they systematically oppose any change that would loosen their grip on this financial windfall. Their lobby, the FBF10, is probably one of the most powerful in France.
The State is wary of touching such a popular product Too abrupt a reform could spark an outcry among savers, especially in a period of inflation. The political risk is huge, and nobody wants to take risks on an issue that, on top of that, isn’t clearly on the table. The opposition, whoever it may be, will clearly seize on the issue in the media to attack.
Social housing is already short of funding Any cut in the funds allocated to social housing would deepen the sector’s crisis, already under pressure with rising needs and output in the doldrums.
Savers are attached to their tax-free nest egg Taxing the Livret A or lowering the ceilings could trigger an outflow of deposits to other investments, which could weaken the whole model. Indirectly, that could serve the banks’ interests, but having the deposits on their balance sheets is already an end in itself.