The story of Casa Isula actually begins in 2014, when the SCI (a French property-holding partnership) is called Villa Long Chemin. At the time, Villa is still married and Albertini declares herself single. It is at her home, on rue Maupassant in Cannes, that the registered office of the SCI, whose capital they split equally, is set up.
In summer 2016, a company is created, Villa d’Ailleurs. Albertini takes 48%, Villa 40% directly, and the rest via Clav, his Luxembourg holding company. Then shares in the SCI are moved up into Villa d’Ailleurs.
The shareholding will, surprisingly, change constantly, every year, until 2019, when Villa’s holding company owns 95%. That said, it isn’t unusual for one partner to gradually increase their stake, consolidate their holdings and slowly ease the other one out.
What follows, on the other hand, is more surprising. Because in 2021, it goes the other way. Over the summer, the company Albertini & Co (later Tigliola Resort) is created, 50% each, with Albertini running it. Villa and Albertini now both appear as divorced and are living together. And each of them hands their shares to this new structure.
The following year, management of Albertini & Co passes to Villa, and the former manager takes back 49% of the SCI’s shares.
Then in 2023, Albertini & Co becomes Tigliola Resort, is now run by Vincent Albertini, Chloé’s brother, and the capital is split up yet again.
Is it illegal? Not at all.
Why does it matter? Hard to say for sure, but what follows will provide some answers. Still, it isn’t standard for two partners to change the split of an SCI’s capital every year, without a capital increase, without really changing how it works, and without ever bringing anyone else in.
Still, this is Laurent Villa’s first real property deal. After starting his career in tourism, he has just spent more than ten years in the restaurant business. So, as he sees it, the logical next step is hotels. And more precisely: luxury hotels. Seems legit.
As with his restaurants, the financing of Laurent Villa’s property (in which Chloé Albertini is now a full partner) goes through crowdfunding. In 2022, two years after the €2M raised on Raizer for the Tribeca Montparnasse, and a few months before the three Tribeca deals on Tudigo, the project is financed in two tranches on the platform.
It is also one of the first big properties financed by Tudigo, which until then had mostly done equity. It is the SCI Villa Long Chemin, represented by Albertini & Co and its chair Chloé Albertini, that is looking for between €500K and €750K over 24 months at 10%, with quarterly interest and repayment at maturity. The only security offered is the personal guarantee of the director (who is not named). End of the deal: March 2024.
One detail in the previous paragraph, and in the marketing documents, nonetheless caught my eye:
Spotted the mistake? Careful, it’s technical, but any expert on the subject would have seen it. The company issuing the bonds is the SCI Villa Long Chemin. Except that… well, that’s illegal. The French Commercial Code2 provides that:
the issuing of bonds is only permitted for joint-stock companies that have existed for two years and have drawn up two balance sheets duly approved by the shareholders.
While the company has indeed existed for two years, it is obviously not a joint-stock company since, as the name suggests, an SCI is a civil partnership, divided into partnership shares rather than stock. As for Albertini & Co, the SAS (a French simplified joint-stock company) was created in August 2021, so it would not have been eligible either, any more than it was when it issued the second tranche in May 2022.
But the issue was still possible under certain conditions: the law provides exceptions to the two-years-and-two-balance-sheets rule for joint-stock companies. An SAS less than two years old can issue bonds if:
Because lawmakers obviously wanted to protect investors by imposing a maturity threshold and the ability to get a view of the company’s financial health.
But nobody finds anything to object to, so Tudigo finances €750K in February 2022, then €1.5M in May 2022.
But by the way, what exactly is the project?
At the end of November 2016, SCI Villa Long Chemin, which will be renamed Casa Isula, buys 3 plots east of Porto-Vecchio for €310K, contributed via a CCA. In May 2018, BNP Paribas Banque Privée grants a first loan of €2.2M over 15 years, with a 3-year deferral, probably with a rank-1 (first-ranking) mortgage.
When the project arrives on Tudigo in early 2022, it is actually fairly advanced, and the structural work is almost finished. The 700m² villa, meant to be sold in 2026, is valued at €8.4M, i.e. €12K/m², at the top end of the range for nearby properties, but perfectly consistent since it is a new build.
In their financing plan, the couple mention €350K for the land and €3.3M of works, i.e. €3.9M for the construction. What seems surprising is the financing plan announced by Tudigo.
Let’s go through the sum again for any VCs reading:
Why the hell would a €3.9M project need that much money? BNP + CCA alone = €3.7M, so why raise so much, and in two goes?
Three possibilities:
According to several cross-checked sources, and Laurent Villa himself, Casa Isula reportedly cost around €8M, when according to him it was supposed to cost €4.5M-€5M, which is already inconsistent with the structure given by Tudigo. But it’s true, building works can be unpredictable.
Again according to him, the structure should have been:
To vouch for Laurent Villa’s solidity, since his name appears everywhere on the documents, Tudigo touts the success of RX Venture, whose reality we now know but which, in 2022, the platform may genuinely not have known about. And also his €20M of assets across 10 high-end properties:
A slide with two properties and videos is shown.
The building on the left is simply the town house on rue Maupassant where Villa and Albertini live, which she inherited with her brother from their father, Marcel, who died in 2020. That is the famous €6M town house, which is therefore not an acquisition at all, and whose price, as we’ll see, is not that high.
As for the second project in Saint-Vallier-de-Wiey, a village that doesn’t exist and which probably refers to the “Farm and forest estate in Saint-Vallier-de-Thiers” in the presentation, the photos are absolutely gorgeous and meet the ecological standards Tudigo wants. The video then linked to the website LaurentVilla.com (now offline), to a page called “Villa Loin De Tout” [Villa Far From Everything].7
After months of research, I managed to locate it.
Just kidding.
After 10 seconds of reverse image search, I found out it was an architect-designed house in Massachusetts, by Hutker Architects and Martha’s Vineyard Interior Design. And the photos come from an interior design website8. The reality is that Villa d’Ailleurs has never carried out a single project, and neither has the Albertini-Villa couple.
Suffice to say that, on the basis of what is stated, Laurent Villa’s property portfolio is limited to what he wants to finance on Tudigo, and the rest belongs to Chloé Albertini, following her father’s complicated estate. Because when Marcel died, a hidden brother turned up from the United States to claim his share. After long negotiations, an agreement was reached… and the brother died as suddenly as he had appeared. Which held up the settlement of the estate for a long time.
Be that as it may, at the end of 2023 the budget is indeed closed with €3M from Artemis to finish the works. This line shows up in a rather strange way in a draft balance sheet.
It’s strange because:
But above all, the €1.5M Tudigo debt… is not on the balance sheet. Even though it has never been repaid.
What we do see, though, is that nearly €2.8M remains in the accounts, and that €2.8M was sent to Casa Isula.
And conversely, we can see that Resort received more than €2.2M from another Tigliola company, called Cap d’Antibes.
And this company is particularly interesting, because according to one source, its shares are what was reportedly pledged as security against the Artemis funds.
So let’s hope this company is really solid.