After months of investigation, it seems fairly clear to me that the Covid excuse no longer holds. Because the timeline is crystal clear:
Inevitably, the quality of the due diligence is seriously in question.
Raizers can be given the benefit of the doubt for a financing in 2020. Admittedly, it was for a restaurant, in the middle of Covid, but it is not impossible that the restaurants’ real situation was not yet clear, and it appears established that forged documents were used.
SquareStones can also be given the benefit of the doubt: its investors praise its work, and in November 2021 it too was fooled about the lease and did not know about the delays that were beginning.
You could even say the same of Tudigo, which granted a first financing a few months later. But how do you explain the ten or so that followed, for nearly €10M, a quarter of everything Tudigo Immo raised? Asked at the time of my first newsletter, Stéphane Vromman replied as follows:
He told me to be very careful on the specific subjects I raised, since we were naming people and players. He confirmed that on these subjects the necessary checks had been made, and pointed out in passing that, as a CIP, the French status for crowdfunding investment advisers, the platform did not have access to the national register of people banned from running companies. He added that he did not know whether that was information it was legal to disclose publicly.
It has to be said that this is untrue. Because as time went on in 2022, how could anyone miss the restaurants’ mounting difficulties? The delays piling up, notably on Raizers, which were easy to check. As for Laurent Villa’s management ban, two clicks on Pappers, the French company-data website (I don’t know what we would do without them…), were enough to see that Laurent Villa had three past insolvency proceedings, and that in the Play Distribution one, a management ban was mentioned.
Laurent Villa’s profile on Pappers.
Which, as I have said several times, is not enough to disqualify Laurent Villa for life from running or financing any business. But which should, at the very least, have prompted a closer look. As should the weak signals about the restaurants, and the obvious lack of due diligence on the parent companies.
One day, platforms and intermediaries will have to understand that handing out yield does not exempt them from being held to account.
And regulators will have to remind them that immunity is not a business model.