💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

5 Arrows, 1 Exit

The sun is shining on Paris when the new chapter in Harvest’s story is made official, in August 2024: after five years under Five Arrows, the company passes into the joint control of two private equity heavyweights, TA Associates and Montagu Private Equity.

The news leaked in the trade press just before the summer, when a journalist put the deal at an estimated €500M. But the process had been launched back in 2023, and talks reportedly began in early 2024 with several interested funds, including Blackstone and Cinven, before the Montagu/TA duo’s offer was picked in early May 2024 and closed at the end of July.

What sets this change of ownership apart is less the swap of one fund for another than the nature of the team now in place. Five Arrows makes way for a pair of investors with vast resources: TA ($45bn in AUM9), an American private equity giant specialising in growth investments, and Montagu (€14bn in AUM), a British fund known for helping tech companies expand internationally.

The scope of the acquisition thus covers every entity held by Financière Winnipeg, the top holding company, and the archipelago of companies that house the various software products.

To understand the bet (and the valuation), you have to dive into the sector’s strategic analysis. According to market watchers, Harvest is on an impressive trajectory: a CAGR10 of 17% over five years, of which 14% organic and 3% through acquisitions, reaching €64M of ARR in 2023 and around €70-75M in 2024.

The strategic goal for 2024-2028 is even more ambitious: doubling revenue to €131.4M by pushing hard internationally. The idea is to move from a modular platform to a fully cloud-based solution covering the whole front-office value chain of wealth management, in a fast-growing addressable market estimated at €1.6bn in 2028. The company aims to double the share of its revenue earned outside France (10%) and push its EBITDA margin above 50%.

The deal is a prime example of profitable SaaS assets coming back into favour (20x EBITDA, slightly above the norm), in an M&A climate where multiples are shrinking. The buy-and-build strategy is reinforced here by highly recurring revenue (nearly 87% in 2024) and excellent client retention, with an average NRR of 109% over the recent period.

A Clockwork Deal

The price paid by the duo takes €495M as the base valuation for 100% of Financière Winnipeg’s capital. But as always, that figure is only the starting point of a far more complex financial equation.

  • A base amount of €495M;
  • Plus daily adjustments between signing and closing, adding around €2M to the amount at closing;
  • The repayment of around €46.3M of convertible bond11 debt;
  • €79.2M of senior debt taken out with institutional investors, whose repayment released the security held over the group’s operating companies;
  • And the shareholder loan granted by Five Arrows, repaid in full at closing.

That adds up to a financial outlay of more than €540M (including €411M in cash for the holding company’s shares), under a locked-box mechanism, which sets the price from accounts already closed (in this case, those for 2023), greatly simplifying things given the large number of parties. 58% will be financed by TA (€333.5M) and 42% by Montagu (€333.5M). 13 so-called Tier 1 investors also come into the capital through an SPV, including Fauvel, who reinvests more than €5M, alongside Harvest executives (CFO, CRO and so on), who get access to preference shares and will sit in the governance. As well as a hundred or so employees known as Tier 2.

Part of the sum is paid in cash through a central account that then handles the payout to each seller. The other part takes the form of a transfer of shares in exchange for shares in the investment vehicles, allowing reinvesting shareholders, notably key managers, to join the new adventure through the SPVs Ceres InvestCo 1 or 2, set up for the occasion. All through a fairly complex structure.

At the top of the structure sit the real economic buyers: Montagu and TA, acting through a joint investment vehicle. The full ownership chain is like a set of Russian dolls: each entity houses another, in a nesting that (partly) hides direct ownership but guarantees effective control.

Montagu + TA → Ceres Holding🇬🇧 → Ceres PikCo🇫🇷 → Ceres MidCo🇬🇧 → Ceres Groupe🇫🇷 → Financière Winnipeg🇫🇷 (Harvest)

What sets this structure apart from classic set-ups is the mechanism used. Intermediate companies were created specifically to pool the non-cash contribution of the shares. Each level of the chain receives the shares in exchange for new shares issued by the receiving company, with no cash payment.

This nested structure optimises the deal’s tax and legal set-up. It offers flexibility for possible future restructurings and makes it easier to manage the different classes of shareholders, while keeping the investment funds’ control over the acquired asset indirect but effective.

Montagu and TA also protected themselves with the usual private equity rights: drag-along12 and tag-along13 rights, pre-emption and exclusion rights in the event of a conflict with a minority shareholder, and the ability to force minority shareholders out in an IPO or sale.