On 18 September 2025, 240 BHV suppliers receive the same email37. The store's sales director announces a big event: a ringmaster (or should that be ringleader) and scratch cards. He suggests they adjust their staff's hours accordingly.
And he forgets to use Bcc.
All 240 addresses are visible. The boss of Le Slip Français, the French underwear brand, hits reply-all, proposes joint action, and opens a spreadsheet where everyone enters what the store owes them. In 3 days, some forty companies discover they are in the same boat. The total climbs to €3.9M for the BHV, plus €1.3M for the regional Galeries Lafayette stores. Management's reply arrives a few hours later. In Bcc, this time. It is signed by Karl-Stéphane Cottendin, appointed head of the store 6 months earlier.
What they wait, on average, is 11 months. The store pays its suppliers in 331.6 days and collects from its customers in 34.7. When the law sets the payment deadline at 60 days.
How long the store takes to pay, and to get paid
2023 annual accounts of SEGM BHV.
During those 11 months, the money stays in the bank: the store that never made money under Galeries Lafayette ends its first year under Merlin's rule with €25.9M of cash, a profit of €1.1M, and even treats itself to paying tax. At the same time, the group's main property company loses €8.2M and has €2M to hand. That money doesn't come from the banks: the BHV has not €1 of term loans, and the cost of its financial debt is 0.1%.
💡 How a department store pockets other people's money
More than half of the BHV's sales are made on commission. The brand keeps ownership of its goods and pays its own sales staff. The store lends the floor space, takes the customer's payment, keeps its cut, and passes the rest on to the brand.
Between collecting and paying out, the money sits with the store. The longer the delay, the more it keeps.
57% of merchandise sales work this way. At 31 December 2023, €15.6M had been sold, collected, and never passed on to the brands. On an annual flow of €28.7M, that is more than 6 months of sales the store is sitting on without having earned them.
Merlin, for his part, denies it.
In September 2024, there are no unpaid bills: just longer payment times, 45 days at most, the fault of a store that has no accounts department and is still plugged into Galeries Lafayette's systems. According to him. A dozen suppliers affected, at most38. A year later, it is still a tools problem39. In April 2026, before the Lyon court, his lawyers once again blame the IT system inherited from Galeries Lafayette. The judge dismisses the argument for lack of evidence and even orders the store to pay damages for vexatious resistance40. But Merlin couldn't care less.
He says he is free to set the contractual terms with his suppliers, and that they are then free to accept them or not.
There is still the law. All the same. Something he doesn't seem unaware of when he has another go at legend-building at the end of July 2026, interviewed by French broadcaster Jean-Jacques Bourdin13:
The contract said 10 days, the law says 45 days, he argues; they paid at 30 days on average, so they were within the law.
Except that it isn't true. An accounting document even gives the exact figure.
331.6 days.
With Bourdin, as in the press or before the Senate, he plays it down:
He concedes that there were payment difficulties with some suppliers, which he says he does not deny.
He talks about it in the past tense. Including at his hearing before the Senate, in January 2026.
Even if some remain, he told senators, a large part of the payment-delay difficulties had been resolved.
That is false. Frédéric Merlin lied before France's national representatives, and here is why he cannot be unaware of it.
In the autumn of 2025, the brands leave, and everyone thinks they know why. Dior, Guerlain and agnès b. walk out. The public version comes down to one word: Shein. Some say so themselves, they don't want their window display 2 floors below the Chinese retailer's.
Except that Dior didn't wait for Shein. Parfums Christian Dior sued the BHV in 2025, almost 5 months before the announcement41. And it wasn't the first: the earliest known ruling dates from 4 March 2025, and at B.B.L. the formal notice dates from 30 September 2024, a year before the email to the 24042. In reality, the store was already being deserted by suppliers fed up with unpaid bills when Shein arrived.
So they demand their money. At least fifty or so legal actions from July 202543. The industry federation puts the tab at between €13M and €17M in February 202644, and the range moves to €50M-€100M in July45. Longchamp wins €1.1M. Petit Bateau, €104K, after 17 years of working together. And Le Slip Français, the one that had started the collective, ends up leaving too.
Others stay and pay in other ways. In November 2025, several small firms in the store had to lay off staff, because of late payments, to keep their concessions going. Even the water came within a whisker of being cut off in mid-2026. And the unpaid bills also hit software suppliers and the security guards.
Not that the context is neutral. French ready-to-wear has been dying for years, and it is dying without any help from the BHV. 1,500 clothes shops closed in France in 2024 alone. Textile industry employment has fallen from 400,000 in the 1970s to 60,00046. Camaïeu, Jennyfer, Kookaï, San Marina, André, Minelli, Comptoir des Cotonniers, Kaporal: the list of brands that have vanished or are in insolvency proceedings is longer than the list of the store's unpaid suppliers.
So several of those demanding what they are owed were already in poor shape.
But a collapsing sector explains losses. It doesn't explain 11 months to pay suppliers against 34.7 days to collect from customers. It doesn't explain €25.9M in the bank while the brands wait 11 months. And it doesn't explain what the store does with the money it keeps.
In court, Merlin loses almost every time. At least 31 rulings go against his companies.
The Kooples wins €953,876 on 3 October 2025, split between the store and the company that runs the 7 former Galeries Lafayette stores. The firm that guards the store, €776,014 on 14 November, a debt the BHV had acknowledged to it by email 2 months earlier. Guerlain, €366,457, and at the hearing the store's lawyer turns up without raising the slightest objection. Gant, €222,766. Sandro, €183,021. De Buyer, €182,144. B.B.L., €154,654. Le Tanneur, €144,505. Bocage, €122,799. Moulin Roty, €107,08142. But Armor-Lux is still waiting for €429,00047.
The rulings cited, in euros
The same script everywhere. The store acknowledges the debt and asks for more time, 6 months, 12 months, sometimes 24. Again and again, the courts describe the same mechanism. In November 2025, a Paris judge notes that the store's own accounts department acknowledges bank blockages, and adds €28,211 for abrupt termination: 4 days' notice, after an 8-year relationship. The Lyon judge, the one who threw out the IT excuse, goes further, 3 months after Merlin's statements to the Senate40:
Because of the way a commission-based retailer is paid, the court finds, SEGM BHV holds the cash from the sales it collects.
In Paris, one ruling even fails to understand why the company isn't paying when it is not in financial difficulty48:
The group's companies, the court finds, show neither that their financial difficulties are real, nor that they could keep to the proposed payment schedule if it were ordered, nor even that they have started to pay.
Nor is this peculiar to the Paris store. In Metz, the mayor describes one of the group's shopping centres, with broken escalators and unrepaired doors, as increasingly run-down49.
When he speaks to the Senate, the 2 biggest rulings in the case have already come down, in October and November. €1.73M awarded, fifty or so cases pending, and one ruling where his own lawyer turned up without contesting anything. That is not a large part of the difficulties resolved. It is the opposite.
And while the unpaid bills pile up, Merlin treats himself to 2 hours in May 2025 to promote himself on Legend and tell the story of starting out with a €15K student loan.
That bill was paid.
The worst part of the story is that the BHV's unpaid bills… are much smaller than the group's, which has made late payment an accounting strategy.
In 2022, the group's main property company owed its suppliers €15.8M. Roughly its turnover for the same year.
This company runs no store. It has no tills, not a single employee. It owns buildings. And it was already making its suppliers wait more than a year in 2021, 2 years before Merlin went anywhere near the BHV. By 2024, it is at more than 2 years. In the same financial year, one of the group's property dealers goes from under 10 days to more than 8 months: no shared IT, no transition to manage. And the company that employs the group's staff comes close to 20 months in 2023, in a financial year of which only 7 weeks came after the takeover.
The property dealer, meanwhile, makes money that year, has cash and almost no bank debt. Nothing forces it to make its suppliers wait 8 months.
It does it anyway.
Average payment time in days for each group company. The BHV is only 7th out of 11
Filed annual accounts of the group's companies, 2020 to 2025.
The store everyone said wasn't paying its suppliers is the fastest payer in the house. And the best tool: it is the only entity in the group that takes in cash every day.
Which is handy, because none is being made anywhere else. The group's main property company loses money a little faster every year: €6.6M in 2021, 6.8 in 2022, 8.2 in 2023, 9.1 in 2024. It had made €1.4M in 2020. The last time.
And there is one thing the BHV has that the rest of the group barely has: people. €7.45M in salaries and social charges over the year. The property company has no employees. Nor does the company that owns the shopping centres. The parent company has one.
The group's other employees are all housed in a single company, the one that bills management services to the property companies. It carries €6.6M of payroll in 2025, or 56% of its costs. It is the only other place in the group with offices, employment contracts and payslips.
It is also the only one in the group that actually works. It manages the shopping centres, it bills €15.4M of services to the house's property companies in 2025, and it takes 445 days to get paid. The group owes it €18.8M. It has €54,299 left, nearly half of which is work already done that it hasn't even invoiced yet. So it doesn't pay its suppliers either. 347 days. And to stay afloat, it borrows from the group that doesn't pay it: what it owes the group quadruples in 2 years. It is the only company in the house that owes money to the others.
Everywhere else, they are the creditors.