Above an enormous photograph, in capital letters, across 3 storeys of façade:
“L'AFFICHE QU'ON N'AURAIT PAS DÛ FAIRE” [THE POSTER WE SHOULD NEVER HAVE MADE]
Followed by an exclamation mark. The one a kid uses when he does something stupid while looking the grown-up straight in the eye, just to see.
Below it, 2 men in suits, and between them a small long-haired dog, held around the middle. His name is Satchi. On his left, Frédéric Merlin, 34. On his right, Donald Tang, executive chairman of Shein. World's first opening on 5 November, the poster announces. In Paris, then. The photo itself was taken in Los Angeles1. Along the left edge of the banner, running vertically in tiny type, another city: LYON RCS 922 623 269, a company registration number.
Behind the covered façade is the Bazar de l'Hôtel de Ville, the BHV. Not a building. An entire block, bounded by 4 streets: Rivoli to the south, Archives to the west, Verrerie to the north, Temple to the east. Nearly 45,000m² of retail space, plus a second address in the Parly 2 shopping centre, in the Yvelines west of Paris. The main store occupies 52 rue de Rivoli. BHV L'Homme, the menswear store, is at 38 rue de la Verrerie, on the other side of the block, and goods lifts run between the 2. They cross the block and carry pallets from one building to the other. The ventilation and heating run the same way, with no regard for street numbers.
A trinket seller from Annonay swallowed it street by street, over 40 years. Xavier Ruel first has his hosiery sold by hawkers in the streets of Paris, and notices that the best pitch is always the same one: the corner of Rivoli and Archives, opposite the Hôtel de Ville, Paris city hall. He sets up there in 1856 with his wife, Marie-Madeleine Poncerry, and Parisians call their shop the Bazar Napoléon2.
The name comes from a stubborn legend. In 1855, Empress Eugénie's carriage horses bolt in front of the stall, Ruel throws himself at their heads, and the imperial reward is said to have let him open the shop. Nobody has ever proved it, everybody repeats it, and it ends up standing in for a birth certificate.
The method, on the other hand, is on record. Ruel adds hardware to hosiery as early as 1860, then tools, then everything else, and the bazaar takes over the neighbouring buildings one by one until it fills the whole block. The street numbers still show it: a single façade carries 50, 52 and 54. When the trinket seller dies, in 1900, the business employs 800 people.
In the basement, the hardware department still takes up floor space that rival department stores gave up long ago. Drawers of screws sorted to the tenth of a millimetre. Behind the counter, a salesman who finds the part number without looking at the label.
A galvanised iron bottle rack, a spiky hedgehog designed to drain bottles upside down, sold by the hundred in every bazaar in France. Marcel Duchamp buys one in these aisles in 1914, aged 27. Takes it home. Does not alter it. Decides it is a work of art3.
“This choice was based on a reaction of visual indifference with at the same time a total absence of good or bad taste… in fact a complete anesthesia.”
Marcel Duchamp4
The original has vanished. What the Centre Pompidou holds is a 1964 replica, made under the artist's supervision and acquired for the collection in 19863. Asked at the time how to replace the lost piece, Duchamp suggested… buying another one at the BHV5.
There you have it. That is the store, the one with the drawers of screws, hidden that day behind an advert and a chihuahua, that the Galeries Lafayette group buys in 1991. The Moulin-Houzé family, owners of the place, adds a second building on rue de la Verrerie, BHV L'Homme, in 2008, then renames the whole thing BHV Marais in 2013. And the store starts losing money, without management ever managing to turn the curve around. It doesn't even have its own accounts: its payroll and supplier payments go through the group's systems.
In the autumn of 2023, all of it is up for sale. The brand, the customers, the drawers of screws, and the 1,064 people who work there. And it is the man on the left of the poster, 32 at the time, who is going to take the lot. Except the building.