💥 Zero Bullshit

Devialet: the inside story of a court-supervised rescue

How did the brand fall apart in 15 years?

It’s an understatement to say that Devialet’s troubles made a lot of noise in autumn 2024. Barely a year after its management was abruptly ousted, the news that leaked this summer of a procédure de sauvegarde, France’s court-protected restructuring for companies that are struggling but not yet insolvent, caught more than a few people off guard.

But before getting to the heart of the matter, I’d like to remind the now 33,500 subscribers (and everyone else) that what keeps this newsletter alive, the deep dive into the real funding of Ynsect (in French), the analysis of the fall of Luko (in French), or the inside gossip on SCPIs (French non-traded property funds), is the information I gather and analyse, but above all the sources who trust me enough to get in touch.

The point of this newsletter isn’t to publish raw information. Nor is it to write yet another article on topics the press has already covered at length, and which, on the whole, it covers properly, though usually in fairly short formats. On the contrary, the idea is to pick up cold stories, or to take hot ones against the grain. Case in point: the two most-read stories in the start-up section of Les Echos1 (Ynsect, Blast) had been covered here first, in depth.

Several newsletters and LinkedIn columns have already come under pressure, but the one on Blast earned me two emergency summary proceedings, for alleged defamation and breach of trade secrets. So far, that has meant three hearings, a lot of wasted time and several thousand euros in lawyer’s fees (50% more than Zero Bullshit’s entire revenue over 18 months).

The first ruling, on the trade secrets claim, found there were no grounds for emergency proceedings on Blast’s requests, and ordered the company to pay costs, including €5,000 to me in legal fees. But an appeal is still possible, as is a full trial on the merits.

Illustration for the issue “Devialet: the inside story of a court-supervised rescue”

In its submissions, Blast asked for the identity of a source, demanding to know how I had obtained certain information.

For the source. Because nobody should suffer the fallout of accurate information published, in the words of the ruling, as part of a debate of general interest. Even if this source, who had initially pledged support, suddenly vanished.
For the newsletter. Because who would hand information to an outlet that gives up names at the first sign of pressure?
For me. Because I believe my work, even if it isn’t journalism in the strict sense, and even if, according to the same ruling, it is covered by the same provisions that apply to journalists, means nothing if it stops at publication, without commitment.

This ruling once again enshrines freedom of expression and confirms that these articles serve a debate of general interest (the Luko, Ynsect and Blast cases were widely discussed in the small specialist world, and the information published here was picked up and cited). Even so, the fate of journalists, and more broadly of content creators, has never been so precarious.

Which is why, with no obligation whatsoever, and to keep Zero Bullshit free to read, you can still:

Illustration for the issue “Devialet: the inside story of a court-supervised rescue”