💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

Soft pedal

In reality, Devialet is like one of those one-hit wonders whose name you’ve forgotten but whose chorus you still hum when it comes on the radio. A brand with one product it can’t renew, and whose various follow-ups struggle to exist.

While the French brand struggles to sell €100M worth, Sonos posts $1.6bn and Bose $3bn. The quality isn’t the same. The positioning isn’t as premium. But the “mass-market luxury” market is far less buoyant, and the vast majority of consumers can’t even hear the difference.

All the more so since, in 15 years, Devialet has become an international company, whose holding company Devialet SA owns 8 subsidiaries in Europe (UK, Germany, France (La Manufacture Devialet)), the US and Asia (Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Japan), an expansion that keeps getting more expensive.

In September 2022, Devialet raised €50M to (once again) grow in China, through Crédit Mutuel Equity and Bpifrance, France’s public investment bank (via its Large Venture fund), with the help of a local partner. On the business channel BFM Business, Franck Lebouchard showed off9:

For Devialet, he said, being profitable is relatively easy: all he has to do is ease off a little on marketing and R&D spending.

He must have forgotten which pedal to press, because group revenue, which rose from €91.7M to €118M between 2021 and 2022, fell back to €111.4M in the 2023 financial year10. With ever bigger losses: from -€24M in 2021 to -€25.2M in 2023.

Internally, things were all the more complicated because Lebouchard’s vision was a far cry from the very product-driven one of the few remaining founders.

So what has happened in the past 8 years, when around 2016 the company was telling everyone it was profitable? A claim confirmed by several sources inside the company and among investors.

Opinions differ widely. Or perhaps they should be stacked on top of each other. For an analyst who worked on one of the deals, the brand badly mismanaged its diversification and, worse still, its expansion. For a business angel who invested, Lebouchard made one bad decision after another, forgetting the product to focus on distribution.

In his words, while losses of 20 or 25M were piling up, Lebouchard was busy selling licensed tech to BYD, which did more for the image than for revenue.

A co-founder is even more scathing.

According to him, Lebouchard forgot what had made Devialet a success. For Lebouchard, the right product was whichever one would slot into a growing market segment, whereas at their scale, it was up to them to come up with the right product for the market.

It’s true that Devialet’s many launches flopped. The brand arrived too late in portable audio and failed to anticipate the major innovations. Including noise cancelling, which only arrived in 2021 with the Gemini earbuds, when it had long been standard at Bose, Sony or Apple. And once again, the price was far too high for a product that, this time, was well below its competitors.

No doubt this pile-up explains why, among everyone interviewed, Franck Lebouchard is unanimously disliked. For 5 years, he loved telling anyone who’d listen that EBITDA was positive, when everyone on the board knew that Covid had finished off a (his) shaky strategy.

Since the partnership with Free (whose boss, Xavier Niel, is an investor through Kima) in 2018, Devialet has been limping along between small-time announcements, and above all, no results. Apart from the failed collab with Huawei and a vague licence with BYD, little remains of the promises of the €100M round with Foxconn, the biggest Chinese electronics contract manufacturer.

Mid-September 2023. At a wannabe keynote, Franck Lebouchard unveiled the second version of the Gemini at the Palais Garnier, the Paris opera house, hoping to borrow some of the venue’s prestige. He learnt abruptly that he was out a few days later. Staff were told by email on 9 October, straight after the board meeting. Charles-Henry Tranié, a board member since 2012, took over the reins on an interim basis. This former VC, a tech and telecoms specialist, is also (above all?) close to Marc Simoncini, with whom he used to be a partner.

In the wake of this, Pierre-Emmanuel Calmel, the last co-founder still in place, left the group. Devialet tersely explained that this marked a new phase of development.