Porte de Clichy, Paris, this morning. At the Paris judicial court, 13th chamber, room 2.01, the atmosphere is electric. Black robes weave between clusters of savers trying to find their way, badge in hand, through this judicial maze. 4,772 people have joined the case as civil parties (victims who take part in the criminal trial), according to the committal order sending it to court.
Their very real loss prowls the corridors just as it haunts their lives. More than €800M invested; close to €1.2bn with interest. From 8 September to 3 October 2025, twelve hearings, three weeks. A judicial marathon for an extraordinary savings fraud.
Facing the judges: Gérard Lhéritier, 77, the man who turned rare manuscripts into a cash machine. It wasn’t his first venture: in the 1990s, he had already set up a company offering investments in Monaco stamps, which ended in bankruptcy. Placed under formal investigation as early as March 2015, after Aristophil, his company selling stakes in manuscripts and autograph letters, went into compulsory liquidation, he appears alongside about ten other defendants. Among them, Michel Perronnet, Philippe Samson and Jean-Jacques Itard, the heads of the Finestim network, spearheads of the sales push through CGPs, France’s independent wealth advisers. A notary, Jérôme Gautry. A Parisian antiquarian bookseller, Jean-Claude Vrain. A chartered accountant, Denis Potier. Even a law professor, Jean-Jacques Daigre, architect of the legal structures. As if the scam had needed every kind of respectability to thrive.
The charges fall like a bureaucratic litany: organised-gang fraud, misleading commercial practices and, for some, misuse of company assets. The trial will have to establish whether the fraud committed between 2009 and 2015 was intentional. The defendants each face up to 10 years in prison and a €1M fine.
But let’s stop for two seconds.
Because this criminal trial that has everyone’s attention arrives after the battle is over. The fall started in Belgium: Aristophil’s subsidiary there was declared bankrupt as early as December 2014, thanks to commissioner Marc Piron, triggering the raids in France three months later. Meanwhile, the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, had already sounded the alarm as early as 2003, then again in 2012, about these atypical investments in letters and manuscripts, outside the scope of MiFID: but the regulator could warn, not punish. And while thousands of victims waited for the trial to open, the civil courts were getting on with it. Since 2019, methodically, ruling after ruling, they have built a body of case law that has made Aristophil a pariah, and even redrawn the boundaries of advisers’ duty to advise.
But to understand how more than 30,000 savers came to believe that a letter from Einstein was worth its weight in gold and that a Sade manuscript was a safe, sensible investment, you (also) have to look elsewhere.
You have to look at the shadow army. The heads of the adviser networks are among the defendants, but the vast majority of the salespeople on the ground are not. The 600 to 800 intermediaries who pushed the Aristophil product remain hopelessly absent from the criminal proceedings. The criminal court will only judge the design and management of the system, not the mass execution of the selling. From a Toulouse adviser’s plush office to a Versailles pensioner’s flat, these advisers spread the good word.
Tangible, prestigious, uncorrelated: that was the line.
8% a year, presented as risk-free: that was the promise.
This is where the equation becomes chilling. A Ponzi scheme, as the prosecution suspects, gift-wrapped with a bow by professionals who should have asked the right questions. Such as: how can a manuscript come with a mirror buy-back promise at +40% in five years when nobody is buying it? Or better: who sets the price, and who checks it?
Without them, essentially, no Aristophil affair.