💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 05

Wilful Blindness

Yet the warnings were there. In autumn 2009, the archivist and curator Rémi Mathis published a blog post criticising the mix of museum and business around Aristophil. He later took it down, citing a risk of defamation22. That set the tone.

But the warning eventually escaped the circle of curators. On 31 March 2011, UFC Que Choisir, France’s best-known consumer association, sounded the alarm on these strange investments, pointing to overvaluation and the lack of a secondary market. Heritage professionals privately denounced the artificial creation of a bubble that stopped them acquiring items for public collections. Private archives previously deposited in institutions were sometimes taken back by the heirs to be sold, including archives of the novelist Romain Gary sold to Aristophil. The Syndicat de la librairie ancienne, the antiquarian booksellers’ trade body, asked its members to stay out of purely speculative operations that undermine trust in the trade. But who listens to party poopers when Einstein is smiling out of the sales brochures?

It took until 12 December 2012 for the AMF to publish a warning against atypical investments, reminding investors that these offers were not subject to the protective rules covering financial instruments and that the sales documents were not reviewed by the AMF.

On 6 December 2012, the AMF referred the matter to the DGCCRF, which on 6 February 2014 drew up an official report for misleading commercial practices. The problem? These products did not fall within the scope of financial instruments. The AMF can warn, not punish. A gaping hole in the regulatory framework.

Aristophil exploited this loophole, and it took the Hamon Act, a French consumer-protection law of 17 March 2014, for the rules on so-called miscellaneous goods investments to be tightened: a mandatory filing with the AMF, registration, regulated advertising. Too late for the 18,000 investors who had already put in €850M.

In January 2014, as payment failures multiplied, informal exchanges between government departments showed the urgency. The Culture Ministry contacted Tracfin, France’s anti-money-laundering unit. The State was finally moving, but the pyramid was already wobbling.

Even when the courts struck, nothing stopped. On 20 November 2013, the Paris high court (TGI) recognised 313 De Gaulle drafts as public archives. Aristophil carried on. After the raids of 18 November 2014, the company still had the nerve to claim that the AMF had validated its business. A blatant lie. On 26 November, the AMF publicly denied it, stating that it had neither approved, nor cleared, nor registered Aristophil’s products. Manipulation to the very end.

The critical voices were there. Specialist journalists, independent experts, brave professionals. They all pointed to the same flaws. Against the weak signal from those in the know, the cultural showcase acted as a screen. Aristophil brandished its lawyers and its collection of ministerial endorsements. The warnings ran into the museum on boulevard Saint-Germain, the official openings, the catalogues signed by recognised curators. Respectability as a fortress.

Only in July 2017 did the AMF publish its blacklists of miscellaneous goods offers. The regulatory framework was tightened after the event.

Shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted.