💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

The Iliad odyssey

Can we do the same thing without getting burned, without crossing that line?

That question, which became Xavier Niel’s obsessive mantra, may sum up the entrepreneur on its own. Not just a slogan from a manager in a suit and tie. No. The confession of a kid who never stopped playing the arsonist, lighting fires in the neat garden of French capitalism, while taking care never to let the flames lick his own hands.

Before the fortune, the cameras and the boardrooms, there was a young man of barely 24, in a 1991 Paris that knew nothing of him. A kid with no prestigious degree and no address book, who laid the first stone of his empire by buying Fermic Multimedia, a modest online services company. He would soberly rename it Iliad in 1995, as if to announce the epic to come.

Late 1990s. Under the harsh neon of the internet cafés sprouting like mushrooms in the streets of the capital, a new social drug is hooking its first addicts: the internet. While the telecoms giants charge astronomical prices to enter this new world, Niel sniffs the air with the instinct of a wild animal. He doesn’t see consumers, he sees prisoners waiting to be freed. In 1999, he launches Free like a brick through a window: internet access with no subscription, paid only by usage. The dinosaurs of the CAC 40, the Paris stock market’s flagship index, snigger in their boardrooms.

In 2002, the same Niel strikes even harder. The Freebox lands in French homes, bringing triple play (internet, phone, television) to the masses and forcing the competition back to the drawing board. A decade later, it is Free Mobile’s turn to shake up the market, smashing prices that had been kept artificially high for years. The French discover they had been paying three times too much for their mobile plans. And their savings propel Xavier Niel into the very exclusive club of French billionaires.

But behind the meteoric success lurks a shadow. In 2004, as Free grabs market share at breakneck speed, investigating judge Van Ruymbeke1 places Niel under formal investigation for aggravated pimping and for handling the proceeds of corporate asset misuse. The founder had invested in establishments offering massage parlours. A month in pre-trial detention follows. On the Place de la Bastille, banners spring up: “Libérez Niel”, “Free Niel”. Because by then, the man is already more than an entrepreneur: he is a symbol, almost a guru to some.

His rise should have shattered against the cold walls of a courtroom. When the judge’s gavel2 comes down in 2006, after a month behind bars and weeks of holding his breath, the verdict tears through the air like a thunderclap: cleared of the pimping charges, the sword of Damocles that would have pulverised his reputation, but given a two-year suspended sentence and a €250K fine for handling the proceeds of corporate asset misuse. The sharks of the competition, already set to carve up Free, put their knives away, disappointed. For the business press, it was the logical end for an over-ambitious upstart. For the establishment, a well-deserved lesson. This troubled period taught him caution, as he would admit himself, and he has kept the mantra quoted at the start ever since.3

Far from being floored by adversity, Niel seems to come out stronger. His rivals, who had popped the champagne when he was locked up, quickly sober up. The anti-establishment figure even becomes France’s favourite boss.4 But behind the scenes, a merciless war is raging.

Because Free, for all its success, remains cruelly vulnerable. For years, the cartel of mobile operators SFR-Orange-Bouygues has refused to let competition play out and colluded on prices, as the courts would later find5. And behind all that stand the French state and two big industrialists, Patrick Drahi, owner of SFR, and Martin Bouygues.

  • Free has to rely on its rivals’ physical mobile network;
  • Free has to use its rivals’ physical copper network;
  • The Freebox only works if it carries every TV channel, including TF1, France’s biggest channel… which belongs to Bouygues.

The Autorité de la Concurrence, France’s competition watchdog, may side with him, and he will eventually get his own infrastructure, but that doesn’t really help him grow the business.

Is Xavier Niel mad, reckless or a complete idiot? No idea. Either way, he goes to war despite the threats, even when his rivals pop the champagne while he is in prison. And the threats are very real.

Relations with Patrick Le Lay, then CEO of TF1 (owned by Bouygues), reach new heights of verbal violence. In the middle of the dispute over the broadcasting deal, Le Lay tells Michael Boukobza, then managing director of Iliad, about a dream:

He dreamt of him last night, nailed to a wall, covered in darts. It was horrible. Be careful, he adds.

Then comes the barely veiled threat against Niel’s children.

Le Lay has noticed there are young children. All these legal problems with the TF1 group must be complicated. Especially with young children. And what are their names again, he asks.

Niel reacts immediately. He picks up the phone and storms into 32 avenue Hoche, the Bouygues offices, to confront Le Lay in person. The meeting almost turns into a brawl. Niel grabs Le Lay’s knee and sets the record straight, with whatever force it takes.

In the hushed corridors of power, it is whispered that Le Lay never mentioned Niel’s children again after that episode. Relations remained oddly cordial until Le Lay’s death in 2020. As if, beyond the brutality of the exchanges, a mutual respect had settled between two men who knew how to play by their own rules.