Stones remember the shocks that shaped them. And the Villa Montmorency did not escape the torments of the century: history, capricious and brutal, always found its way in, leaving visible scars and others, more insidious, hidden beneath the appearance of luxury and silence.
The Franco-Prussian War of 1870 is the first to shake this sanctuary. When Paris is besieged, the shells do not just plough up the capital’s fortifications: they also rip open several houses on the estate. The monumental gateway with its caryatids, designed by Jean-Baptiste-Jules Klagmann, an ostentatious symbol of an aristocratic past, is pulverised by Prussian fire. It will never be rebuilt. The gates that replace it are no longer decoration but practical necessity. The time for majestic entrances is over; the time for secure access has come.
The Thiers wall, built in 1840 to protect Paris, seals the neighbourhood’s fate. Cut off from the Bois de Boulogne, Montmorency becomes a world apart. After the French defeat at Sedan, the Prussians enter Paris. Far from the turmoil of the insurgent districts, the villa escapes the fighting, but not the fallout. After the Paris Commune uprising, the city must be watched and gridded. Several streets are redrawn: rue Pierre-Guérin and rue Raffet are no longer just thoroughfares; they become lines of demarcation.
From then on, the villa turns in on itself. A movement born of necessity soon becomes a habit.
In the France of the Belle Époque, as the gulf widens between the elites and the working classes, the Villa Montmorency locks itself away. The Dreyfus affair, which sets the country ablaze between 1894 and 1906, strengthens the reflex to keep the world at arm’s length. Political tension, rising nationalism and social mistrust push the great families to dig in a little further. Side entrances are locked, discreet surveillance is installed, and the residents keep to their own.
And yet walls, however high, never fully protect you from History.
In the final months of the First World War, while Paris lives under the threat of air raids, the Villa Montmorency is not spared. On the night of 15 to 16 September 1918, a German raid hits several strategic points in the 16th arrondissement. One bomb rips open a house at number 12, avenue des Tilleuls; another hits 51, boulevard de Montmorency, blowing out windows and doors and spraying shards of stone and glass across the sleeping façades. Further on, on boulevard Suchet, a shell strikes bastion no. 61 of the city wall, exposing this once-sheltered neighbourhood even further to the jolts of the outside world.
At the Armistice, Montmorency closes its gates again. But it is only a respite before the next shock.
During the Second World War, while Paris lives under the German Occupation, the Villa Montmorency is no exception to the fractures running through French society. What had been a haven of tranquillity for the Paris bourgeoisie becomes a hushed theatre of tension and ambiguity, where old money and newcomers live side by side in an atmosphere of mistrust, intrigue and, sometimes, compromise.
But behind its grand façades, the villa is also put to an unexpected use. From 1942 to 1944, a discreet nursery for infants operates at 81-88 boulevard de Montmorency, its garden opening onto avenue des Sycomores. Officially, it is a refuge for abandoned babies. Unofficially, some of the children it takes in were born of unions between French mothers and German soldiers. At a time when such children are often rejected, condemned to anonymity or secret adoption, the Villa Montmorency becomes an invisible link in a story nobody wants to own.
The Fondation d’Heucqueville, which runs the nursery, operates under the supervision of nuns. Some babies are taken in by the state child welfare service, others adopted directly by influential families. One of them will have an extraordinary destiny: in 1942, Georges Pompidou, then a young senior civil servant and later President of France, adopts his son Alain at this address. The former president will never speak publicly about the adoption. Only much later will the story resurface, revealing another side of the Occupation, more intimate and more troubling.
More secret still, a flat at 13, rue Pierre-Guérin serves as a clandestine maternity ward. A stone’s throw from the Foundation, it is kept secret so that nothing gets out unchecked. This is where some mothers give birth anonymously, before their children are handed to adoptive families under the cover of an erased family tree.
Meanwhile, the villa goes on playing its role as a silent jewel box. Some of the mansions on boulevard de Montmorency and avenue des Tilleuls are said to have been requisitioned by German officers, although the lack of formal proof leaves room for doubt. What is certain, on the other hand, is that the neighbourhood stays out of the fighting during the Liberation of Paris in August 1944. But as the capital goes up in flames, retreating German troops are still occupying some residences in the area.
When the war ends, the villa closes its doors again. Official accounts avoid mentioning what happened here. As if the villa itself preferred to forget.
But the walls saw it all, and memory, even under gilt, never fully fades. And war never ends all at once. It lingers in the cracks of daily life, in belated score-settling, in hatreds that find one last echo before the curtain falls. The Liberation does not just mark the end of the Occupation; it also exposes the wounds left by four years of suspicion, calculation and everyday betrayal.
Especially since, in Montmorency, the war did not unleash tanks or shake the façades, but it left a dull tension in the air, the tension of ambiguous allegiances and neighbourly secrets. And sometimes, those secrets turn ugly.