Some exiles you choose and others are forced on you. When he bought a plot at 38 avenue des Sycomores around 1900, the writer André Gide thought he had found a refuge, an anchor away from society Paris, where he could write far from the obligations of the age. What he did not yet know was that this villa, already marked by a taste for keeping to its own, would gradually close in on him.
At the time, the Villa Montmorency does not yet look like an ultra-secure fortress. It is a neighbourhood in the making, aimed at a wealthy elite, but where Haussmann-style architecture and neo-Louis XIII influences still dominate. Gide does not care for convention. He wants a house in his own image: modern, functional, stripped of every useless ornament. An avant-garde chalet, a clean break with the spirit of the estate.
From the first sketches, the revolt begins. This project rising among the classical façades bothers people. The writer runs into the silent hostility of his neighbours, who take a dim view of this architectural oddity. It is not a matter of stone or taste; it is a question of social code: in this microcosm where bourgeois identity is also set in brick and cement, Gide’s modernity sticks out.
The fight is muffled, but real. The paperwork gets bogged down, the building work drags on. Until it is finished, Gide moves temporarily into a small house at number 18 bis, a modest building dating from 1853. He watches his building site and monitors progress, without suspecting that what was meant to be a space of freedom will become a place of confinement for him.
He will live at 38 avenue des Sycomores for nearly thirty years. Thirty years of voluntary isolation, but increasingly heavy. Where some writers seek the buzz of the salons, Gide chooses seclusion. In his vast living room with its shutters often closed, he works in sparse light, preferring the half-dark to the glare outside. It is not just an aesthetic choice, it is a way of life: Gide cuts himself off from the world and, gradually, the world cuts itself off from him.
But the world, for its part, keeps on shaking.
In March 1916, the First World War saturates Parisian life. The capital lives under threat, but the Villa Montmorency remains a bubble. Gide, always withdrawn, is absorbed in his work, impervious to the shocks of the conflict. Until an unexpected visitor knocks at his door.
On 27 April 1916, the poet Guillaume Apollinaire turns up at 38 avenue des Sycomores. He arrives marked and weakened. A few weeks earlier, on 17 March, while at the front, a shell fragment pierced his right temple. Rushed away, he was operated on for a brain abscess at the villa Molière, at 57 boulevard de Montmorency, before being evacuated to the Val-de-Grâce military hospital. He is no longer quite the same man. His body is battered, his gait hesitant. But his mind has stayed intact. He still has the verve and fire of poets, that way of speaking as if he were already reciting his next line.
It is not their first meeting. Gide and Apollinaire have known each other for a long time, linked by the Nouvelle Revue Française, the literary review. In 1911, one had asked the other for an article on Jules Romains’s L’Armée dans la ville [The Army in the Town]. Then their exchanges had grown rarer, tinged with mutual admiration but a latent incomprehension. Gide: methodical, measured, cerebral. Apollinaire: overflowing, excessive, lyrical. Two opposite visions of literature, of the world, of life.
That night, Apollinaire is looking for an exchange, something shared. He talks about the war, his wounds, the poetry that never leaves him. He recites verse, hoping to find in Gide a reaction, an echo. But the writer facing him stays silent. Distant. As if choked by this encounter with a man transformed by the war, he who had stayed safe.
The unease settles in. The silences stretch. Apollinaire understands that this visit will lead nowhere. He thanks Gide and leaves, without anger, but with the lucidity of poets who know when a bond is impossible.
It will be their last face-to-face meeting.
Two years later, on 9 November 1918, Apollinaire dies in his flat at 202 boulevard Saint-Germain, struck down by Spanish flu, two days before the Armistice.
Gide says nothing. No letter, no public word. Nothing to suggest what he thought of that last meeting. Perhaps he thought back on it sometimes, in his big living room with its closed shutters. Perhaps he regretted that silence, that distance which, that evening, had kept him from answering a man who had come looking for a little light.
Gide’s isolation gradually becomes a stranglehold. The refuge he wanted ends up suffocating him. The Villa Montmorency, which he had chosen as a sanctuary, turns out to be a trap. He is alone there. Alone in a community that always saw him as an intruder. Alone in a house he never really loved.
In 1928, he makes up his mind. He sells. He leaves 38 avenue des Sycomores, quits the Villa Montmorency and moves to 1 bis rue Vaneau, closer to the beating heart of Paris. Far from this neighbourhood which, beneath its air of tranquillity, was never anything but a world of walls and hostile stares.
Today, nothing remains of this story. No plaque. No official memory. Just one house among others, hidden behind gates. A house where, one evening in April 1916, a wounded poet knocked at a door and found, in return, only silence.