💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Conflicts, of interest

In any case, these revelations clearly ratchet up the tension, which is starting to be felt in Tudigo’s teams. So much so that the subject comes up in several annual reviews. One employee writes in hers.

She says that very quickly she found herself dragged into their tensions (between Laing and Vromman, my note) and was regularly called on to act as a mediator.

From mid-July, as the regulatory problems start to be raised, Vromman begins to think about his exit, which he eventually mentions off the record at the end of July. He takes HR director Souvannarath into his confidence; she had been promised a managing director role, plus a stake in the company.

After several governance set-ups are considered, it is decided that Souvannarath will be promoted to deputy managing director at the end of the summer, with a raise of nearly 50%, part of it paid through invoices. The announcement is made to the whole company on 30 August, then given to the press. On that occasion, GOD’s assignment is also widened: on top of the club deal project, he is handed portfolio management and the clean-up of the regulatory problems. Not least because in 2012 he had managed to rescue the retail funds of Tocqueville Finance, sparing 55K individual investors from losses.

But it is only in October that Vromman tells Laing he is leaving, opening the door to a possible sale, even a partial one, of his shares. And from October, the tension rises another notch as no agreement is found. On the 29th, Laing puts the problem as an ultimatum: basically, it’s him or Vromman. Behind the somewhat brutal way it is put, it is in fact the whole problem of the company’s governance that is being raised, since apart from the two of them, nobody has a say. No expert, no board, no supervisory board.

While the company churns through negotiated departures and redundancies to try to restructure and keep its costs down, the two bosses each draw up plans to carry on without the other. And without the other really knowing. Internally, the situation becomes unbearable for most employees, who have to put up with the pressure of a company losing momentum, and the now-public war between its bosses, each trying to build his own team. Some then speak of violent management, of a climate of terror or of staff in tears, pointing as much at one boss as at the other.

Enter a new protagonist. Originally introduced by Lauriot, Pierre-Etienne Lorenceau is also the second-largest investor in Tudigo Partners. This impact BA, who once headed a media group, has long moved in private equity circles. At one point presented as a possible chairman of the SPV, he is brought in, apparently by mutual agreement between Laing and Vromman, to act as a mediator. After all: he too has an interest in everything going well.

On 3 December, at a Tudiflash, a regular internal meeting, Vromman announces that he will actually leave in the summer of 2025. Laing then thinks he can quickly take back control of the company, whose business is threatening to slow down, even though the losses (-€600K in July) are starting to shrink while Q4 was looking bad (December will even end in the black). The next day, Laing asks Lorenceau to take over as chairman of the SPV, to restore some balance.

Then on 6 December, a notice of general meeting goes out to the 700 shareholders to find another chairman, the current one being Vromman.

The notice explains that, because TUDIGO has become a PSFP, it must set up a run-off procedure and comply with the requirements on preventing conflicts of interest.

Shareholders are invited to vote remotely but in reality… only Lorenceau’s name is put forward. At the very moment he is in the process of buying Vromman’s shares.

Lorenceau denies any conflict of interest, speaks of a rhetorical trap and defends himself.

He says that as long as he is not chairman, he has no obligation to make public his discussions about buying out one or the other.

Fair enough. And the offers are indeed being made while the 700 shareholders vote. But on Saturday 21 December, Lorenceau is elected chairman of Tudigo Partners.

The news stays fairly secret, to the point that most shareholders will only hear about it a month later, when the battle starts to go public. In fact, to this day, the surprising minutes still haven’t been filed with the commercial court registry, but I have been able to see them. Out of 3M votes, only 728K were represented, 100K of them by Lorenceau himself. And… that detail matters. Because the articles of association are clear: a quarter of the voting rights had to be present for the vote to be valid…

Articles of association of Tudigo Partners, quorum and majority.

EDIT 31 March 2025, 12:50pm: the general meeting of 21 December was an ordinary general meeting. In that case, decisions require a quorum of 20% of the voting rights. It was therefore reached, with 24.6%.

But in reality, on 20 December, the day before the meeting, Lorenceau obtains a promise to sell 15% of Vromman’s shares. Then on 23 December, it is Laing who offers to sell all of his shares. On 31 December, Lorenceau files a first LOI through his company to acquire Laing’s shares in Tudigo Holding.

He says that he has indeed been approached (to buy shares), but is in no way a buyer, given the context and the absence of annual accounts, and that he would make any progress or potential purchase arising from these approaches conditional on the final accounts being published.

He goes on to say that he had asked for his term as chairman to start only on 1 January. Except that on 8 January, when he has been chairman of the SPV for a week, he sends Laing a new LOI to buy all of his shares, valuing Tudigo at €7M to €10M.

According to him, he ended the discussions as early as February.

Taking advantage of a relative lull, Lorenceau therefore carries out the usual due diligence, even though no LOI has yet been signed. That is in fact one of his lines of defence on the conflict of interest: it was a framework, but Laing never signed it.

In that capacity, he talks in particular with GOD, who tells him about the problems he has uncovered. The obvious problem is that Lorenceau now has access to confidential information about the company.

He says that when he receives the information, he wears two hats (SPV chairman and potential buyer), that he doesn’t know who it is intended for, but that it benefits the shareholders.

Or not. Should the shareholders have been told that Lorenceau was a buyer at the time? Not necessarily, according to him, as he considers his interests aligned with those of the SPV’s shareholders. Which is obviously untrue.

Because a fortnight later… it is GOD who puts forward a takeover plan, to Vromman and to Laing, which both of them also turn down.

In mid-March, Laing suggests to Vromman that GOD and Lorenceau be sidelined as a precaution. Not only because each of them is in one camp, but also because they are two potential buyers, and so have possible conflicts of interest. Vromman firmly opposes it.

In reality, what mostly starts to emerge is a dividing line where:

  • GOD wants to roll out a business plan led by Laing, focused on private equity, which is why he came on board in the summer;
  • Lorenceau wants to keep Vromman to continue Tudigo’s current business.

And it has become clear that, whatever happens, one of the co-founders will have to leave the ship, or the deadlock will last for ever. Well, not quite for ever, since even if the company still has €2M in cash, it won’t survive without any business.