💥 Zero Bullshit
Conclusion

Five things to change

Zero Bullshit has been writing about crowdfunding for several years, and every time the conclusion is that the PSFP status, France’s licence for crowdfunding platforms, is badly designed. In April and then in August 2025, this newsletter published fifteen reform proposals (in French). This investigation confirms five of them, which ought to be emergencies for the regulator, to make sure the interests of retail investors are protected.

1️⃣ The bondholders’ representative must be independent of the platform.

At Tudigo, the same company selects the borrower, collects the commission, drafts the guarantee, chairs the vehicle and represents the creditors. When the guarantee is not signed, it is again the one deciding whether to go after its own mistake. There should be no ownership link between a PSFP and the bondholders’ representative for its issues.

2️⃣ Guarantees must be checked before the money is raised.

A personal guarantee missing a date, pledges never signed, a first-demand guarantee from a company with €1,030 in the bank, another from a company liquidated within the year. These 4 guarantees were sold as protections, and none of them protected anything. There needs to be a common standard and an audit of whether each one is real before the raise.

3️⃣ Accounts must be audited and published as soon as you raise money from retail investors.

A company that does not file its accounts leaves no one able to judge its health. Here, neither the borrowers nor the vehicles file them, and the 1,200 investors in Tudi Holding 101 found out what their holding was worth 3 years after paying for it. Filing should be a condition of the raise, and failing to file grounds for suspension.

4️⃣ Run-off management must be funded by the platform, not by the saver.

The programme of operations filed with the AMF said it would be funded from the group’s profits. The entity was never created, the money was spent, and the bill lands on investors 3 years later, even though fees have already been paid. A business continuity plan should be published in full, provisioned from the moment money is raised, and enforceable against the platform.

5️⃣ It must be possible to hold platforms liable.

A falsified criminal record that nobody checks, a plot of land never bought and financed 6 times: these are not market accidents, but serious mistakes. Today, savers cannot act alone, and the only one who can act for them is the one who made the mistake.

The regulator must act. And fast.

It is already too late for the platforms that are falling.

But the question will inevitably come up again in the future.