💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 08

Plaza Spicy Sausage

On 18 February, the sentence comes down: Stéphane Plaza is given a 12-month suspended prison sentence for repeated violence against a partner. M6 immediately applies its long-prepared plan and takes him off air. The channel was ready for this outcome; if anything, an acquittal would have been the problem, because internally his departure had already been decided, even if some executives would have liked to save him.

In SPI agencies, the reaction mirrors the country. Some franchisees think it’s his private life, others believe he should no longer speak in public, others still find the sentence too light. But in the end, their opinions matter little. What they are living through is the discomfort of carrying the name of a fallen celebrity, in a market that is already hurting.

Many are leaving the network, and plenty use the occasion to tell the local press about their departure, as they try to reposition themselves. Since the conviction, around ten agencies have already announced they are leaving15.

But leaving comes at a price. Off the record, two franchisees tell me about exit fees of several tens of thousands of euros. A third even mentions more than €100K in compensation. He has already started talks with another network, but he still has several years left on his contract.

On Wednesday, a crisis meeting was scheduled between the shareholder and the franchisees, who were expecting (at last) strong measures, given that M6 Créations had had plenty of time to think, and that the channel already seemed to have an exit plan. Well… nope.

  • No change of name;
  • No exit for Plaza from the capital (which would cost M6 a fortune);
  • No reduction in the cost of leaving the franchise.

The 568 survivors were offered nothing but a cut in the monthly subscription.

And nothing on Plaza.

The reason is that, in high places, the question is still divisive, and every option is apparently still on the table today.

  • The now least likely: backing Plaza. At one point, a documentary supporting the presenter, featuring well-known figures, was on the cards, but nobody believes in it any more. Especially as Plaza is no longer the advertising cash machine he once was: the shows he fronts bring in 7 times less advertising revenue than at their peak.
  • The most radical: closing the network. But, whatever becomes of Stéphane Plaza, Stéphane Plaza Immobilier is a cash machine for M6 Créations, where it accounts for more than a third of revenue. Of the €18.6M in revenue in 2023, €6.5M came from SPI, while the other subsidiary, M6 Editions, posted just €419K in revenue for €107K in dividends.
  • The most obvious: changing the name. It’s clearly the option that has had the most support, except that nobody has agreed on how to do it. Use the name of a show? Find another figurehead? Launch another programme? Slap on the channel’s name? Invent a brand-new brand? So many questions that never get settled quickly in a group of that size, with sprawling ramifications, and which, on top of that, changed boss last year, with long-serving chief Nicolas de Tavernost replaced by David Larramendy, former head of M6 Publicité, the group’s advertising sales arm, and M6 Interactions. One source tells me, however, that it could create a contractual problem with the presenter, and that there’s a big legal question between, on one side, the wrongdoing he may have committed, which harmed the company, and on the other, that same company, whose success is down to his own image. And the law never gives a yes-or-no answer…
  • The easy way out: waiting. That’s de facto what has been chosen. Because whatever solution is picked, putting it in place will take time, cost a lot, and only happen if franchisees (and clients) go along with it. Every crisis has a beginning and an end, at least in the media. A market recovery, combined with some franchisees closing for lack of business and others who believe in the project, could quite simply get the machine running again without a hitch.

And yet, in early 2024, M6 had decided that Plaza would be taken off air:

  • Quietly, through the back door, if convicted;
  • Letting him say whatever he wanted if acquitted.

Along with him, the two flagship shows produced by Réservoir Prod, which had stopped filming for several months, were also supposed to end. So the question was not whether Plaza would go, but how. Yet over the year, the strategy seems to have shifted. Why the U-turn? Hard to say.

At SPI, Patrick-Michel Khider stepped down as chairman last December, handing over to Gilles Charron, a former sales director who had been chief executive since 2020. Khider had taken over the role when Crémiers died in 2019.

But behind the scenes, another story is brewing, one that some would like to be the post-Plaza future.