💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Plaza, hold the anchovies

In mid-2022, the property market starts to turn. Some point to the war in Ukraine as the trigger, but it had been brewing for a while. Since the Covid crisis, central banks had flooded the economy with liquidity, without equivalent wealth creation. By resorting massively to unconventional monetary policies, they set off a wave of inflation that eventually caught up with the market.

Property is the perfect illustration.

Historically low rates allowed an unprecedented flood of money, artificially boosting demand. More than just a driver of the market, these financial conditions changed buyer behaviour: with loans at 1%, the same monthly repayment could buy a bigger or better-located home. That boosted buying power fuelled soaring prices, quarter after quarter.

With hindsight, there’s no doubt the price explosion was first and foremost a direct consequence of those rock-bottom rates. And when central banks decide to tighten the screws, the market soon feels the effects.

I’d already covered the subject in two newsletters:

But to set the scene, here are a few figures that help pin down the problem, looking at it from a bit of a distance7.

Mortgage rates for households (%)8
All markets

Change in home prices9
By group of cities, index 100 = January 2014

Transaction volumes in France (excluding the overseas territory of Mayotte)1011
To the end of May 2023

Monthly amount of new home loans
Excluding renegotiations, in €bn12

Since then, property has been suffering. Everywhere, rising rates have pushed prices down, the logical result of higher risk and bigger monthly repayments. But in France, the adjustment is much slower.

Volumes, on the other hand, take a brutal hit. Transactions collapse. For years, the market had organised itself around an annual pace of 1.2M sales, well above the 21st-century average of around 850K. In 2024, the figure should come in around 780K, before gradually climbing back to around 850K in 2025-2026.

And in a market running in slow motion, there are too many middlemen. Physical agencies hold up better, but mandataires, more precarious and more exposed, are leaving the sector in droves. Traditional agencies are cracking under the pressure too: 1,232 closed in 2024, up 225% on 2023.

But for SPI, the storm is far from over.