💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Bust Club

So, given the number of complaints and proceedings brought (dozens of rulings against it in the civil and commercial courts, fines from the CNIL, France’s data protection authority, fines from the DGCCRF, the French consumer protection and anti-fraud agency, a suspension by the ACPR, France’s banking and insurance supervisor, and so on), how do you explain the regulators’ failure to react?

True, in April 2023 the ACPR banned it from signing up any new contracts. But that ban would push SFAM, already on the brink, to step up the undue debits.

How could the regulator miss the problem?

How could every single authority let it happen?

Sfam has been ruled against at least 14 times for illegal debits, and at least 12 times for forged or non-existent mandates.

Why was no action taken to stop these practices, which were clearly systemic?

While it is true that the group’s sales methods were more than questionable, it was the SEPA system that sat at the heart of the fraud, and the ACPR could not have been unaware of it. And the commercial court did stress how serious the case was.

The banks’ responsibility inevitably raises questions. What is the point of a mandate, which must be signed, if nobody checks that it has been signed or that the signature is valid?

Why do debits go through when the mandate was revoked several years earlier?

The ACPR, and more broadly the Banque de France, France’s central bank, and SEPA must put back on the table the flaws of a system that lets anyone debit anything.