So no, despite its bad press and its shocks, the SCPI is not a bad investment. Nor, for that matter, a miracle investment.
It’s a vehicle. With real advantages: pooled risk, an entry ticket of €1,000 instead of €100,000, delegated management, a historical yield above inflation. The product has been through three major crises (1991, 2008, 2023). Partners who stayed in have never lost money over the long term. Although, as our friends at the AMF say: past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
In reality, the problem has never been the product. It’s what surrounds it.
Subscription fees that fund 7% retrocessions when life insurance tops out at 1%. Performance indicators that change every ten years, according to ASPIM’s political interests. TDs annualised on six months of track record. Valuations frozen while the property market corrects by 20%. Queues getting longer while the sales brochures talk about liquidity under control.
And above all: conflicts of interest on every floor. The CGP who pockets €500 for placing €10,000 in SCPIs against €100 in life insurance. The management company that charges acquisition fees on every disposal and purchase. The insurer that guarantees liquidity to its clients by suffocating the vehicles. The comparison site that ranks SCPIs by the commissions it earns, not by their quality.
The 2023-2024 crisis revealed nothing new. It just made visible what had been there from the start. SCPIs backed by banking networks, stuffed with Paris-region offices bought at the top of the cycle, are left with price cuts of 10 to 20% and withdrawal queues lasting several years. Independent SCPIs, diversified across Europe, built with discipline, keep paying 6-7% with no liquidity problems.
The real divide isn’t between “old” and “new” SCPIs. It’s between disciplined SCPIs and constrained SCPIs. Between independent managers who can say no to an overpriced acquisition, and subsidiaries of banking networks that have to place the inflows at all costs.
Still, the saver doesn’t have access to this way of reading the market. They see a TD, a unit price, a brochure. They trust their adviser. And three years later they discover that their SCPI is worth 15% less and their units are stuck.
Hence this newsletter. Not to say “don’t invest in SCPIs”. To say: invest knowing what you’re getting into.
And if we had to keep a few principles, by way of summary:
Now, it’s up to each of you to make your own choices.
Advertisement
This newsletter is entirely sponsored by Louve. This means Louve was involved in preparing it, approved its angles and is mentioned in the editorial. But Louve did not directly take part in the writing
⚠️ Warning: investing in SCPIs exposes you to a risk of capital loss and a liquidity risk.