So, do these disposal plans hurt savers? Well… it depends.
Back to Capimmo. At the end of August, Primonial drew up a plan to sell €2.2bn of assets over 3 years. And that is what the NAV is calculated from.
Say my fund was worth 100 on 1 January.
With the market falling, the valuers say it is worth 85.
My disposal plan forces me to sell at less than ideal prices: starting now, I apply the “quick sale” discount to those assets, so my fund is now worth 75.
The reality is that the intrinsic value is the same in 2. and 3. But in 3., I apply a “just in case” NAV.
And it is actually completely fair to savers.
Those leaving the fund, who are therefore responsible for the quick sales, leave with less money. They pay a kind of “liquidity tax”.
Conversely, for those who stay, the impact is small. They take a paper loss on the market fall, but if the disposal plan is not carried out, or only partly, the NAV will go back up to where it was in 2.