💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

What next?

When I started writing this newsletter, I had a long paragraph on the ECB not using reserve requirements as a regulatory tool (and relying on rates alone).

To general surprise (or indifference), on 27 July it announced it was cutting the interest paid on minimum reserves from 3.5 to 0%: until 2022, this rate was pegged to the main refinancing rate (MRO: 4.25%) before being pegged to the deposit rate (DFR: 3.75%).

This had 2 side effects:

  • Banks were making a killing at the ECB’s expense (€30-40bn a year)
  • They had little incentive to lend

But the reserve requirement ratio itself has stayed fixed at 1% since 2012. Yet many economists have pointed to the beneficial effect it has had in the past, starting with Jean-Pierre Patat in 1987, when he was head of research at the Banque de France. 10

  • The more binding the reserves, the less attractive investments will be (and the more money will be injected into the economy)
  • By adjusting the reserve requirement ratio, the central bank can vary lending volumes without touching rates, and therefore the cost of credit

In an opinion piece at the end of 2021, Jacques de Larosière (former governor of the Banque de France, former managing director of the IMF, which tells you he was nobody’s fool either) criticised the interest paid on excess reserves, which he said were swelling with no gain for the real economy.11

I’m neither an economist nor a monetary policy expert: but there’s no denying that the policy pursued for the past 15 years isn’t working.

The market, for its part, will have to adapt. Impossible to say whether prices will fall far enough to rebalance purchasing power, but it’s unlikely. On the other hand, the decline is inevitable: because a return to very low rates below 2% is no longer on the cards.

Or so we hope.

My name is Benjamin Charles, and I do branding, positioning and content creation consulting for companies in finance, real estate and web3.

👉 Contact me, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es

👉 Follow me on LinkedIn

👉 Book a video call to pitch a project or a service (€150 per call)