So, as an MP from LFI, the radical-left party, wanted a while back, should we just slap rent control on everything, and hey presto, problem solved? Quite apart from the issue of freedom it would raise, and probably a constitutional one too (it would be acting supercalifragilisticexpialidociously unconstitutionally14), it would end up putting off private-sector investors and could destabilise the market accordingly.
The fact remains that there isn’t one rent control, but many very different schemes, as we saw earlier. That’s why, across the hundred or so studies produced, the subjects analysed are fairly different, even if, obviously, most of the research focuses on similar themes.
These studies are often quoted by the anti-rent-control crowd to prove it’s useless.
The reality is a little more nuanced.
Generally speaking, as we saw above, studies show that controlling rents helps contain increases, or even brings rents down. That makes sense in principle. But they also show that it comes with a wide range of side effects that affect the city, or even the whole country, and go beyond property.
Number of studies by potential effect of rent control15
One of the first side effects is rising rents… on homes that aren’t controlled. That applies to city policies that only target certain types of housing, but very often it also applies to neighbouring, unregulated areas, such as the suburbs. That’s what led the French Basque Country to adopt a wide zone, just as Villeurbanne, Lyon’s next-door neighbour, is included in Lyon’s scheme, or the northern suburbs in Paris’s (but under a different scheme).
The other side effect is a drop in supply. But as we saw above, it isn’t systematic, and there can be many reasons for it. Most often in the studies, long-term supply disappeared in favour of something else, notably short lets or leases that allowed exemptions.
Some analyses also show a drop in home ownership, which could be because tenants feel less need to take the plunge.
But let’s take a closer look.
87% of studies16 conclude that prices actually fall. On the other hand, almost all of them find an increase in unregulated housing in cities that applied differentiated policies, with the exception of one study on Lyon, but which already covers part of its suburbs.17
The size of the fall varies hugely between studies, countries and cases, to the point that it’s hard to conclude anything at all. Between -1 and -57% for controlled rents, and between -2 and +14.8% for uncontrolled rents.
Another major difference between the studies is that some look at the short-term impact while others focus on the long run, which makes the figures hard to compare, especially when they span changes in the cycle.
Almost every study shows the negative effect of rent control on mobility.
The only two studies showing the opposite18 are based on very small, unrepresentative samples.
Nearly two-thirds of studies show that rent control has a negative effect on construction, for two main reasons.
The problem is that these figures are often not very significant, because new builds, and this is very true in France, often come with heavy state support that muddies the analysis. The studies showing a positive impact on new builds mostly seem to show that it’s owner-occupiers buying, as a windfall, precisely because investors don’t want them.
With the exception of two studies19, they all show a decline in housing quality after rent control comes in, or rather, landlords letting their properties deteriorate until their value falls… to a yield that makes sense. It always comes back to that.
An effect that could be greatly reduced if rents, and their caps, were indexed to inflation.20
This point is still fairly debatable, since the main factor put forward by researchers is that landlords whose income falls have no incentive to maintain or renovate. Yet several countries have incentive schemes (in France, things like MaPrimeRénov’, the state renovation grant, depreciation allowances, the tax regime for furnished lets, etc.) or coercive ones (the energy rating timetable, decency standards, etc.) that make up for it.
Which may explain why more than half of the studies concluding that housing quality declines have never actually been published after peer review.
Will tenants be able to save by paying less rent and take advantage of properties put up for sale? Or will they enjoy cheaper rents for longer21?
Well, for reasons you can imagine, the hundred or so studies say everything and its opposite, possibly because you need to look over a long period, in a market influenced by many factors, including lending and interest rates.
Still, overall, the general feeling is that tenants could find it easier to become homeowners.