💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 04

Dying on live TV

In June 2022, the producers of Qui veut être mon associé [Who wants to be my partner?], M6’s version of Dragons’ Den, get in touch with Nanaba. The official story would later have it that it was the staff who signed the company up. The start-up sends the equivalent of a due diligence pack, with all its figures.

Olivier Guérin tells me they weren’t especially keen to have Bourbon or Simoncini, two of the show’s investors, on the cap table, preferring to recall the company’s slot on the 19.45, the same channel’s evening news: obviously a huge media opportunity.

Except the recording goes badly.

I couldn’t find any clips of the programme: M6 systematically takes down its replays, presumably so nobody checks the track record of the investments, or whether they ever actually happen. Several entrepreneurs did tell me their offers were either cut or cancelled after the show.

The written record points to two problems.

1️⃣ Weak or non-existent tech.

True, Nanaba is quizzes that unlock app time. And even if few people know how to block apps on a phone, it hardly looks like a huge barrier to entry. But investors don’t normally stop there. They look at traction, scalability and so on. In fact Gabriel Jarrosson of Leonis Investissement was astonishingly surprised to find a French app that matched his usual investment criteria. But more broadly: how many unicorns or big scale-ups have incredible tech? The vast majority of the Next40/120, the French state’s list of its leading start-ups, are software and services, with no deep technology.

2️⃣ The headcount.

Éric Larchevêque, another of the show’s investors, reportedly pointed out that of the twenty or so staff, five work on tech. In his view, the app could have been coded by one person. Two investors who had been approached about the deal confirm this to me.

In their view, a five-person marketing team, that early on, was far, far too much.

Two developers who passed through the company say much the same. One of them explains:

According to him, half the staff were just shuffling paper, and in more than a year the tech team produced absolutely nothing. They were really only there to make the company look big to investors and lend it credibility.

The company did indeed list 19 employees, plus the 2 partners, on its pitch deck at the end of 2020. That’s about €360,000 a year according to Olivier Guérin, but €300,000 a quarter according to the 2022 business plan.