💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 10

Bridge over troubled water

At the end of 2023, new investors are called in to inject funds.

But the deal drags on because the first investors refuse to give up their LP, which is obviously a key condition for the newcomers. The term sheet for a 4.7M bridge round is approved… in December. Enough to keep going in 2024.

Except the company has been out of cash for a month and can’t even pay December’s salaries. Legally, it is insolvent. A board member tells me that when Thierry Vignal broke the news, several investors asked him to put off filing for insolvency for as long as possible. Yet French law requires a company to file within 45 days.

Maxime Hanquier explains that salaries had sometimes had to be paid a day or two late while waiting for a transfer, and that in that sense the company could already have been insolvent several times.

Because, supposedly, start-ups are used to these situations, and it’s normal for them to navigate a financial fog. At least that’s what many ecosystem regulars describe.

This winter, a judge at the commercial court in Bobigny, just outside Paris, thundered back at a company boss that this was CERTAINLY NOT the case.

Because after years of believing that a company doesn’t need to be profitable, that free money is normal (in French), that you have to create unicorns and that funding hypergrowth with no results is healthy, plenty of people think a start-up is a company apart.

The French Commercial Code, and the judges who apply it, say the opposite at every hearing. And the hearings are scathing.

If insolvency is declared late, the company boss can be held personally liable for the debts piling up, on top of being banned from running a company.

What you get is a complete misalignment of interests, with a legal representative trying to avoid his own conviction, and investors pushing as hard as they can to avoid losses, knowing they will never be legally liable before a commercial court.