What does the failure of Masteos reflect? Thierry Vignal doesn’t hide behind excuses.
He thinks he was bad, really bad. He spent badly.
His co-founder is more nuanced and talks about bad timing.
6 months earlier or 6 months later, he says, they would have had time to cut spending. Or to do things differently.
But what is a VC’s role in this situation? As managers acting purely on behalf of others, since it isn’t their own money they invest6, they have a duty to make sure the investment goes well.
On every VC website, you can read phrases like “providing capital” or “acceleration”. None of them talk about hands-on support or more concrete action. And yet dozens of accounts suggest that VCs interfere more and more, especially since 2019.
For a while now, for example, Thierry Vignal has no longer had access to the Masteos company card, and has to get every decision approved, even though he is chairman and therefore the company’s legal representative. One former employee even tells me he was shut out of the executive committee for a time. Others play this down.
The interference is unbearable, replies a former manager at the company, but it’s when management is weak, not to say amateur, that the VCs pile in the most…
While it isn’t the most glaring example, the failure of Masteos is also that of the excesses of a system and an era, when the hope of multiples, funded by the central banks’ free money, poured insane amounts of investment into companies completely unsuited to a VC track.
Because nobody questioned the investments and valuations agreed between elites who convince themselves that they know, even though almost every IPO of the past 10 years shows that the equity rounds were overvalued.
Thierry Vignal illustrates it with an amusing line:
He reckons that with ten plasterers, you’d notice a problem in the numbers faster than with ten graduates of France’s elite engineering schools.
A reality many refuse to accept. Everyone knows these decision-makers come out of the same schools, the same family backgrounds and so on.
But there’s one factor that I think is decisive: where you live.
You CANNOT understand what life is like for an ordinary French person when you’re locked away in Station F, the giant Paris start-up campus, and you’re delighted to have found a not-too-expensive 30m² flat for €1,200 thanks to your €50K salary working on a SaaS nobody understands.
Because real life doesn’t look like that.
And if you don’t understand that, I remain convinced you will be unable to build a product that suits the general public.
Because 100% of people living in Paris don’t need their groceries delivered in minutes when there are as many corner shops as rats.
Because it’s an ecological nonsense that runs against the tide of history.
Because it’s a social madness where you get pseudo-entrepreneurs to work for you and offer them €10,000 if they die under the wheels of a lorry.
Because it’s precisely far from Paris that there are people who need their groceries delivered, even if not in minutes.
In the same way, you can’t grasp the madness of employing dozens and dozens of construction workers with nobody managing them on site day to day, if you’ve never had building work done.
But the ecosystem is going off the rails, carried by complacent media that relay press releases, and blessed by politicians who never miss a chance to claim a success as their own.
It revels in glorifying valuations that make no sense, and shuns those who want to build a different model, one that seeks profitability.
It glorifies appearances and dick-measuring contests while ignoring the reality of VCs whose survival depends entirely on Spray & Pray, and who clench their buttocks hoping to land 2 or 3 future Facebooks to soak up the 95% of write-offs.
Another model exists.
My name is Benjamin Charles, and I advise finance, real estate and web3 companies on branding, positioning and content creation.
👉 Get in touch, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es
👉 Send me a brief for a business project
👉 Book a video call to present a project or a service (€250 per call)