💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 08

Crowdfunding: the mistake of a lifetime

This liquid pref resurfaces on another matter.

In January 2023, Masteos opens its capital to the general public through Crowdcube. Thierry Vignal makes no secret of having done it partly because others had, like the French business neobank Qonto. For purely marketing reasons.

But the timing raises questions: when the round opens and closes, the company is already in very bad shape. Enough to shortchange the 714 investors who put in €1.5M, money Masteos didn’t even need?

Mostly, it comes down to administrative delays. This round was synchronised with the EDF one: a file presented in summer 2022 and closed in Q2 2023. But in summer 2022, the numbers were at their peak.

A situation Thierry Vignal deeply regrets today.

He says he hugely regrets doing Crowdcube, for several reasons. In his view, if private individuals don’t know what a liquid pref is, they shouldn’t play the VC game. So he makes a huge mea culpa over Crowdcube, calling it the mistake of his life. And honestly, he adds, if he had made a single cent, he would try to give it back.

Maxime Hanquier admits that the biggest shareholders through Crowdcube are people close to the founders, executives or employees.3

As its only document, Crowdcube had presented a promotional PowerPoint without a single figure. Without explaining what an LP is… and without even providing the shareholders’ agreement.

Since then, Crowdcube has quietly left France, leaving its many investors with no answers on the site’s forums.
Edit of 4 July 2024: Crowdcube never left France.

The very idea of opening up the capital of unlisted companies is questionable. At a time when a TV show on the French channel M6 makes people believe you can put 6-figure sums into a business in exchange for a percentage, based solely on someone talking for 5 minutes, it’s a dangerous game. All the more so when several of the show’s regulars use that exposure to set up a gamified investment platform.

For the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, an SCPI counts as a complex product. Private equity doesn’t.

Maxime Hanquier doesn’t think just anyone should be allowed to invest. Crowdcube is regulated and supervised, he says, but people get lost. Masteos is a complex project, with 4 business units, international operations, a complicated cap table…