💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 01

The people’s savings account

The Livret A was born on 22 May 1818, in the middle of a Napoleonic hangover. The State, as poor as a church mouse (and the mouse, at least, had a church), was desperately trying to refill its coffers. To do so, an industrialist and banker by the name of Benjamin Delessert, backed by the Duke of La Rochefoucauld-Liancourt, sold the public a brilliant concept: safe savings, open to all, designed to keep people out of poverty and debt.

On paper, the intention was laudable. In reality? It was mostly the bourgeoisie who rushed to sign up. In 1818, only 352 accounts were opened, the vast majority by comfortably-off Parisians. It took until 1835 for the figure to reach 120K, then 2M in 1869. The movement was under way, but it remained limited: in 1890, only 5% of French people had a Livret A. It was in the 20th century that these savings became truly popular: 30% of the population had one in 1910, 40% in 1920 and 47% in 1939.

From 1835, the State entrusted the management of the funds to the Caisse des Dépôts, which kept the money safe and reinvested it in public projects. A well-oiled machine that would last almost two centuries. In 1881, the deposit ceiling was raised to let households save more. But the real turning point came in 1945: the Livret A became a major tool for funding social housing, strengthening its role in the country’s economy.

From the start, it was both a tool for thrift and a political instrument. For Delessert and La Rochefoucauld-Liancourt, the working classes had to be encouraged to save so they wouldn’t become dependent on public assistance. Le Moniteur Universel, a newspaper of the day, didn’t bother with niceties either: it described savings banks as a means of limiting the number of proletarians, a class that could become dangerous1. Behind the social facade, the point was above all to reassure the elites by imposing a form of economic discipline.

The Livret A was at first the preserve of cautious, relatively well-off savers. In 1818, more than half of the first depositors came from the upper bourgeoisie. Only in 1838 did workers make up 42% of holders. Gradually, the product took root in popular culture, to the point of inspiring a vaudeville comedy in 1836 titled La Caisse d’Épargne [The Savings Bank]2.

But behind the scenes, the banks began to take a dim view of this State-controlled model. The money collected escaped the conventional banking market, and its distribution stayed locked down. Only the Caisse d’Épargne savings banks, La Poste, the French postal service (now Banque Postale), and, from 1975, Crédit Mutuel (via the Livret Bleu) could sell it. A monopoly that would last until 2008, before the European Union forced it open to all banks.

In theory, this liberalisation was supposed to widen access and stimulate competition. In practice, the historic players kept their dominance, and the banks, not thrilled by a product that pays little (especially for them), pushed it into the background. Raising the ceilings, meant to encourage savings among ordinary people, mostly benefits well-off households, who are the only ones able to reach them. The result today: the Livret A is an unavoidable savings product, held by 83% of French people and weighing heavily in regulated savings, but with a distribution of funds that doesn’t benefit everyone.

At the end of 20233:

  • The average balance is €7,033;
  • Up €700 vs. 2022;
  • But
    32% hold less than €150;
    16% hold €150-1,500;
    12.7% exceed the €22,950 ceiling (+3pts vs. 2022);
    And these “over-the-limit” savers account for 40% of deposits;
  • What’s more,
    The average balance is €8,802 in Aveyron, €8,227 in Puy-de-Dôme or €8,551 in Haute-Loire (all in central France);
    And only €6,128 in the Nord, €5,979 in Haute-Corse (northern Corsica) and €4,162 in Seine-Saint-Denis, just north of Paris.