💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

Couldn’t Care Less 3000

These failings are anything but trivial. On the contrary, they reflect a public policy of secrecy, one that takes taxpayers’ money for granted and refuses to be held to account.

And yet: it’s the law.

Since 1978, the CADA6, France’s freedom-of-information commission, has existed to help public bodies release the documents they use in carrying out a public-service mission. And since 2015, it has even been written into Book III of the CRPA7, the code governing relations between citizens and the administration.

These documents should normally be made available under the open data programme launched several years ago. Few public bodies have put it in place. None has published most of its documents.

Worse. Public bodies do EVERYTHING THEY CAN to turn requests down.

Over the past year, while investigating, I have had refusals or no reply at all from:

  • The AMF, the financial markets regulator;
  • The ACPR, the banking and insurance supervisor;
  • The Banque de France;
  • Matignon, the Prime Minister’s office;
  • The Ministry of Public Accounts;
  • The Ministry of the Economy and Finance;
  • The Ministry of Ecology;
  • Bpifrance, the state investment bank;
  • The state shareholding agency;
  • France Trésor, the agency that manages the state’s debt.

None of these bodies agreed to hand over the very specific documents requested, and an administrative court has been seized in 3 cases.

While the National Assembly pretends to haggle over a budget that MPs know they will refuse to vote for, so as to push His Majesty the Prime Minister into an Article 49.3, the clause that forces a text through without a vote and exposes the government to a no-confidence motion, which will cost him his head (much to Macron’s delight, rumour has it). While we wonder whether it’s better to raise taxes, or rather to cut benefits (or both). While major tax upheavals are under way that will change lives, for minimal revenue. It is essential that our democracy, gasping for breath, be transparent.

Not because elected officials are paid with our taxes, so as to steer clear of yellow-vest populism and its citizens’ referendum sold as a guillotine for elected mandates, but because public policies deserve to be judged on the evidence. And because those who want to spend time analysing them must be able to do so.

That a public body refuses to hand over the map of strategic oil reserves or of where our nuclear warheads are stored is not up for debate. But that a minister’s chief of staff refuses, illegally, to release the minutes of a meeting between the French Banking Federation and two ministers, at a time when the formula for the interest rate on the Livret A, France’s state-regulated tax-free savings account, was tweaked to stop it climbing too high, and when banks are struggling to sell their own savings products, is a problem.

Democracy doesn’t end when the polling booth curtain closes.

My name is Benjamin Charles, and I do branding, positioning and content creation consulting for companies in finance, property and web3.

👉 Get in touch, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es

👉 Send me a brief for a business project

👉 Follow me on LinkedIn

👉 Book a video call to pitch a project or a service (€250 per call)

You can also make a donation here. Pay what you like, and above all there’s no Substack taking 10% and Stripe 3% 😅.