During this investigation, everyone I interviewed who had crossed his path, and whose relationship with him had soured, described a man who loses his temper quickly and can quickly turn threatening.
I don’t mean the ridiculous exchanges between Benotmane and Bourbon, through duelling Instagram stories, to find out whose is bigger.56
I mean every person who has voiced a criticism, which he takes personally, as a challenge to himself. And I fully expect to be next on the list.
A former employee describes how Benotmane asked her to falsify balance sheets so they could be handed to funds and banks when things were tight. She was in charge of the accounts at the time, and she refused.
Hakim would then publicly call her a pimp and a madam.
That is also what Mous went through, a YouTuber who specialises in investigating scams and similar behaviour online. Benotmane filed several reports to get the videos taken down; they were offline for a while before being restored.
On 31 October, during a live stream for members of Hakisition only, Benotmane laid out his strategy against Mous:
Before adding that he has also sued YouTube France. Which, as a reminder, is a brand and not a company.
Time and again, he describes Mous as a guy who works in a factory and understands nothing about finance, while Bourbon is called homeless, a reference to the life story he regularly tells. Having worked at length with Mous on this investigation, I can say that the guy (who, in real life, drives a lorry) had understood the heart of the problem two months earlier, and that his work made it possible to wrap up this investigation in a few days instead of a few months.
A few weeks after the first videos, Benotmane’s team invited Mous onto a podcast for a so-called exchange of views. The YouTuber agreed in principle, but couldn’t make it on the terms imposed, because of work commitments.
He soon realised that the format would not be in his favour, that the editing could trap him, and when he began to voice reservations, his contact threatened him with a defamation complaint.
After offering to travel to Mous’s town, and following his refusal, Benotmane then shared the address of Mous’s home, where he lives with his two daughters, aged four and six.
A first person, then a second, turned up at Mous’s home in the days that followed, and Mous ended up filing a complaint.
On a great many occasions, I have seen insulting and outrageous messages, sometimes public, sometimes private. But also racist remarks, which fall foul of the law.
Because Benotmane plays the racism card when it suits him, to explain certain failures and to cultivate a sense of community, while making particularly abject remarks. Openly racist ones.
When he talks about kebab-shop staff in the south of France who skip work to go to the match, or when he recounts a scene with a supposed accountant who, he says, told him:
That she was sorry to tell him this, Mr Benotmane, but that it was the names with an Arab connotation that didn’t pay the rent.
And to whom, he says, he replied:
That she should take no more Arabs, and that was that: she should rent to Europeans.
Or when he explains, speaking about his franchisees:
That the Jews and the whites paid their fees on the first of the month [...], whereas the Arab, he says, would tell you not to worry, the Arab would say this phrase to him: “on s’arrange”, we’ll sort something out.
Not to mention these audio clips containing extremely violent remarks about Algerians.
Audio clip from the newsletter (in French)
Audio clip from the newsletter (in French)
Whereas, as we’ll see in the second episode, he would repeatedly use his origins and his success to persuade investors to join his Hakisition club.
For worse, and for worse.