Oddly enough, when all of this happened, Benotmane was supposed to have left his company already. The manager of the franchise company, as of most of the group’s companies, was Guetarni. A job that always seems to come along at just the right moment for Benotmane, unless you believe Guetarni is the unluckiest man alive.
Which leads to several conclusions.
- All the companies collapsed between 2016 and 2017;
- Guetarni is systematically appointed manager when the accounts turn sour.
And the fall would come because a supplier sued Benotmane’s companies. As early as July 2017, S’IN DESIGN won a first judgment against FBH for €57K32.
Yet he had acknowledged the debt in several exchanges, notably in a text message on 9 February 2017 promising payment the next day, an email on 12 February announcing a bank transfer, and above all an email on 19 February in which he does not dispute the debt.33
Smart Retail, for its part, which had sold several restaurant sites, obtained in April 2018 a joint judgment against three group companies (FBH, NKD France and Groupe H.B Holding) for €20K of unpaid invoices for finding commercial premises for their franchises.34 Here too, Benotmane had acknowledged the debt in writing on 4 May 2017, without ever paying.
It was precisely this pile-up of debts and the S’IN DESIGN lawsuit that led to FBH’s liquidation on 13 March 2019, with the date of insolvency set retroactively at 13 September 2017.35
But Benotmane’s lawyers would try a very surprising move: changing the name. FBH would try to rename itself KDH and raise several procedural objections to have the proceedings annulled36. To no avail.
All of it tied to disastrous day-to-day management. Like the famous restaurant in Metz, where a lease was signed for premises on which not one euro of rent would ever be paid. And where the works would never start, as a bailiff would note in February 2022.
Statement of amounts owed after 12 months
Over the whole period, the only credit ever entered on the rent statements was the €7K rent-free allowance granted on signing.
Stranger still, the lease was signed in October 2020 in the name of Woky Moky, described as a company being formed. A company that was in fact never created.
At the end of 2021, Benotmane would even try to have the lease transferred to another company, while saying he would have the funds in early 2022. He got the extension, but never paid.
Even though he had already made a commitment on €20K that he never settled.
Same story in Nice, where the property fund (SCPI) Patrimmo Commerce, run by our old friends at Primonial, evicted a Tacos King after more than €205K of unpaid rent and service charges, and after obtaining permission to seize €140K.
The accounts at the payment firm Treezor and the bank Delubac were seized, but barely €10K was left in them. Especially since, in reality, TKPF, like all of Benotmane’s companies, owes tens of thousands of euros to the state or in social security contributions.
Debts of TKPF
Debts of Nabastille
Because while it was one supplier’s lawsuit that brought everything down, the various entities were buried under unpaid rent37, tax debts38, sundry suppliers39, nuisance claims40 and franchisees41.
When the situation spiralled out of control, a lawyer was brought in to carry out an audit and found more than fifty disputes, with landlords, franchisees, partners, suppliers… and even lawyers.
Notes for the lawyer who will be instructed to sue me (everyone else, skip ahead):
- Ask to be paid upfront, it will spare you the trouble two of your colleagues ran into;
- Send the letters straight to Yoël Abitbol and Yaron Edery, so we don't waste any time;
- If it's only to ask for an adjournment at the hearing, don't bother with urgent proceedings.
Love and kisses.
Still, Benotmane clearly didn’t want any of this getting out, since he spent a long time having his companies’ pages anonymised through a lawyer, although Pappers, the French company-records website, decided to backtrack a few days ago.
From a page on Google
Because whatever you do, don’t mention it, because it annoys him, but following HB’s bankruptcy, Hakim Benotmane and Abdelkader Guetarni were handed a personal bankruptcy order, a French sanction, for 7 years. And since Benotmane plays with words in several podcasts, here is what that means:
For FBH’s bankruptcy, Guetarni got a 3-year ban from running a company, and Benotmane 10 years42. Then another 7 years each for the bankruptcy of Distribab.
What the court holds against the pair is that FBH’s insolvency, meaning its inability to pay its debts, is dated 13 September 2017, whereas it was only declared on 13 March 2019. By law, a manager must report it within 45 days, or remains personally liable for the debts that pile up after that.
The court found that Benotmane, the beneficial owner, had sold the company’s shares to its parent company for €140K, booked to a shareholder’s current account (which rules out, yet again, the idea of an outside buyer), and so remained fully responsible for its management.
The problem is that when the case came to court in 2019, there were €466K of debts, €338K more than at the point of insolvency in 2017. All the more awkward since, again according to the court, FBH’s last known turnover was under €80K. That is why they are held liable.
But worse still: while the company was bankrupt, three new companies were set up to run the businesses while the others were left to die, which amounts to misappropriation of assets, among other schemes.
And while Guetarni was officially the legal manager, Benotmane was found to be the de facto manager, the judge having obviously seen through the little scheme.
But Guetarni would also get:
Each time, the court tried to show that Benotmane was the de facto manager, but in the last 5 judgments, only Guetarni was convicted.
Convicted for acts he never understood, put there as a mere front man.
Because the reality is cruel. Guetarni is just a nice cousin to whom Benotmane offered €200 a month to be the manager of his companies, one day in 2009, in exchange for a signature and his ID card. A few months later, Guetarni had to go to Algeria to bury his father. When he came back, Benotmane told him he was no longer manager, but that he would still keep receiving his pay.
In 2015, Benotmane sent him to the Rambuteau restaurant in Paris, and he says Hakim offered him the management in 2017, which minutes from that same year confirm. He would remain manager until 2021, shortly before the liquidation. In all, he would run eighteen companies. Every one of them liquidated.
After the convictions in 2023, Guetarni ended up filing a complaint against his cousin for forgery and use of forged documents, with the help of a victims’ association.
A few days before that complaint, Benotmane and Issam Benali, who appears on several companies including the Luxembourg ones, were also banned in Belgium from running a company for ten years44, even though Benotmane had had him appointed in 2017 precisely so as to no longer appear.
Benotmane appealed in the FBH case45, and the Court did not default46:
As a result, it broadly upheld the judgment, while accepting that the penalty was no longer proportionate, and cut it to six years.
Hakim Benotmane is therefore definitively banned from running a company for 6 years.
As for the Luxembourg entity NDM Developpement, it was finally, painfully, liquidated in 202447.