Still, one of Benotmane’s major problems is that he has no licence whatsoever. Even if he says he is abroad, and the company behind the club23 is in London, there is no doubt that:
To operate, Hakisition could have relied on the prospectus rules24 in its own name, except that a UK company isn’t eligible. That said, being banned from managing a company in France and Belgium somewhat limits his ability to open a company there, and more broadly to get a licence from a regulator.
Benotmane quickly decides to go through an intermediary. At first, in the early documents, there is talk of a well-known French PSI (an investment firm, in French regulatory jargon), also regulated in Luxembourg. Without the provider ever having agreed to take part, its name is stuck on at least three sales documents for fundraises.
In capital letters, the documents state that the funds are managed not by the club but by [X], a specialist in setting up SPVs.
Followed by the line: a maximum of 149 investors per project. A double problem.
First because the investment firm chose to decline after a quick audit. So you may well wonder why its name was displayed anyway. Second because there is indeed a limit of 150. Except that in no way does it refer to the number of end investors. Because the exemption is very clear25:
“The obligation to publish a prospectus […] shall not apply to […] an offer of securities addressed to fewer than 150 natural or legal persons […], other than qualified investors.”
The spirit of the law and its application leave no doubt: the 149 are not the end investors, but the investors to whom the offer is addressed, even if they don’t invest. As the boss of another investment firm confirms:
At his firm, he explains, an offer can be seen by 149 different accounts. After that it locks, whether they invest or not.
The mere fact that this offer was shown to all of the 300-50026 to 700-80027 members is already a breach of the prospectus exemption.
Even so, Equisafe agrees where three28 other providers refused, and the wording is eventually changed on the documents.
From the FitFit deck
Dated around mid-2025
In total, Equisafe will structure seven deals:
Unlike the other providers, Equisafe isn’t an investment firm but holds the PSFP licence, the European crowdfunding service provider status. But it is in fact under the prospectus exemption regime that Equisafe structures the deals, via SPVs in Luxembourg. As they explain to me:
Equisafe explains that its role as an investment platform is to provide the technology and to handle the legal structuring of Luxembourg SPVs through its Luxembourg subsidiary Qazar Management Luxembourg. When the SPV is set up, and before any operation is launched, it says it makes sure it has proof that the target due to receive the funds exists.
On this point, I asked several of Equisafe’s competitors, a good number of whom are surprised that Benotmane’s track record didn’t come to light. Only the head of the investment firm quoted a few lines above said it wasn’t systematic.
For its part, Equisafe passes the buck to Lemonway.
According to Equisafe, the checks on Hakim Benotmane personally and on HK Club LLP were carried out by its KYC provider, Lemonway. The director, banned from practising in France and Belgium, was able to get a KYC approved on a company because it is registered in England. Lemonway, its payment service provider, in charge of anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing checks, therefore apparently didn’t spot him, Equisafe says.
Also contacted, Lemonway didn’t want to say much, but seemed to be aware of the problem.
Lemonway assures us that it takes its regulatory obligations very seriously and applies them […] It says it has put robust control procedures in place and, in this case, is in contact with all the parties concerned. The situation, it adds, is being closely monitored by its teams and handled appropriately, in line with its legal and regulatory obligations.
Which, incidentally, makes going through a French provider very unlikely, given Lemonway’s market share, and more broadly the attention the affair has recently attracted.
Meanwhile, Equisafe eventually announced officially that it was ending its relationship with Hakisition29.
According to Equisafe, the Hakisition club used its private operations (Club Deal) service. After review, it says, it emerged that the limits set by the regulatory framework had not been respected (more than 150 investors solicited). To guarantee the compliance of its activities and protect its investors’ interests, Equisafe decided to end the operations under way with the club.
Asked more specifically, Equisafe also mentions other problems, notably about whether the investments were real. And yet, in an “official statement”, Benotmane seems to use Equisafe to justify his investments:
Benotmane writes that people claimed they had never got into Mistral AI and SpaceX, and that he answered with proof, including a statement from EquiSafe saying it had pulled them out and refunded the money: proof, according to him, that they did get into Mistral AI and had indeed invested in these companies, except that EquiSafe has discreet clients and didn’t much like the bad buzz.
Equisafe sees things a little differently.
For Equisafe, these public statements were misleading: none of the investments in PERPLEXITY AI (via SPV), SPACE X (via SPV) or MISTRAL AI (via SPV) are direct investments, they are indirect stakes on the secondary market via other SPVs.