💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

Public Menace

Unsurprisingly, then, Hakim Benotmane’s club mirrors his previous ventures:

  • Built on lies;
  • On the edge of legality, or beyond it;
  • With no regard whatsoever for its partners or clients;
  • With a complete inability to run a project from start to finish.

The problem is that it worked: between €3M and €8M collected in memberships, while not a single member has managed to invest, and the rest of the services are, in the view of everyone interviewed, negligible and of very poor quality.

All with highly problematic methods. Several complaints have already been filed against those who dared to speak negatively about Benotmane (against YouTuber Mous and Zero Bullshit, but also several members). Some have suffered harassment or insults, according to several consistent accounts. Likewise, at last Saturday’s event in Geneva, several members were refused entry because they hadn’t fully endorsed what Benotmane himself had said.

On the other side, a small army of people who seem very real appear to like and comment on all the boss’s posts, and to tear into anyone who disagrees. Even though at least three of them are in difficult financial situations, as members of their families have told me.

A situation that looks a great deal like a psychological hold.

And what we have here is a huge collective failure.

  • On the part of the professionals: it took direct interventions for the regulated companies to stop working with him, even though at least one of them had known about the problem for days. While it’s likely that nobody will now risk being associated with Benotmane, it clearly shows the cracks.
  • On the part of the regulators: it will take years before the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, or the DGCCRF, its consumer protection and fraud watchdog, if they ever declare themselves competent, step in, in some token way.
  • On the part of social platforms: a few weeks ago, it was shown that a large share of Meta’s revenue came from scams, that the company knew, and that it did nothing. How many numpties based in Dubai use these channels or systeme.io to sell useless rubbish on the back of tall tales?

While many members (as I pointed out at the start) were perfectly aware of their means and of what they were getting into at first, even if they were misled about the reality, many of those who remain are now in its grip.

That was clearly what Miicode showed in his documentary on Kevin Valfrin.

It’s also what the Miviludes, the French government’s watchdog on cult-like abuses, tends to show, having investigated the practices of David Laroche and Paradox for years.

It’s what has emerged from my months-long investigation into a host of course sellers who have set up shop on the digital high street of LinkedIn and Instagram and who, under the guise of helping you scale, do business or some other bullshittery, fleece poor people who think they can get rich by copying the model of pyramid-selling PDFs.

Will it take a tragedy on the evening news for an elected official or a regulator to take it up?