💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Special Lifetime Achievement Award

Note: this award does not take into account its feats of 2024.
Note 2: since this manager asked LinkedIn to remove one of my posts about it, I hope it won’t do the same with this newsletter.

Some winners you can reward for one specific feat... and others sailed through the whole year. And when it comes to bullshit, how could you not think of Primonial, the French asset manager?

Sold by almost every financial adviser, honoured by every financial awards ceremony where you have to pay €5,000 to display the logo, the manager with €21bn under management was a role model all year long.

First of all in the management reports for its SCPIs (France’s non-listed property funds) published in mid-2023, which don’t say a word about the gloomy outlook. The manager even explains, in substance, that

Primonial REIM France is very well positioned in this respect, thanks to strong inflows and capital that allow it to invest without systematically resorting to borrowing.

Same story with Capimmo, one of its property funds, which waited until the autumn of 2023 to finally own up to the dramatic fall in its assets and announce an emergency sell-off plan.

And of course, a big shout-out to the insurers, whom the French Monetary and Financial Code obliges to provide liquidity for life insurance policies, and who dip into savers’ money to create it!

Finally, a huge red card for Alain Taravella. The founder and boss of Altarea, the French property group, pulled out of buying Primonial a few hours before signing the final deal. Primonial’s executives leaked the figures for the damage far and wide without ever giving any detail on the reasons.

A spectacular, visionary U-turn that deserves to be denounced.
Otherwise, what would I write about?