Among the nominees in this category were property taxation, savaged by the De Courson / Labaronne report, and the splendid, scathing 113 pages of the J’Accuse by the Cour des comptes, France’s national audit court, attacking the State’s (non-)policy on its own property, before property taxation copped the FATALITY from the CPO in December.
But the big winner is in another league.
Because not only is it a huge failure that will end up landing us all in the shit, but it is also put on a pedestal, like the French astronaut Thomas Pesquet coming back down to Earth (whereas Patrice Vergriete, a French minister, still hasn’t).
I give you (and reward): MA PRIME RÉNOV’, the French state’s home energy-renovation grant.
While we need to energy-renovate 1.26M homes a year to meet our carbon-neutrality target for 2050, and Emmanuel Macron set a target (heaven knows how) of 700,000 homes, the Anah, the national housing agency, congratulated itself on 650,000 renovations in 2022, then fewer than 595,000 in 2023.
Some will cry foul over the cut to the Ma Prime Rénov’ budget. But do they know that even with a €1bn trim, the budget wouldn’t be fully spent anyway?
Because nobody understands any of it. Rumour even has it that Guillermo del Toro came up with the idea for Pan’s Labyrinth while trying to get his windows replaced.
The result is an ecological, political and financial disaster. Especially when you actually read the report and see that fewer than 10% concern major works, the only ones with any real energy benefit.
Another report, which apparently nobody has read1, puts at fewer than 6% the share of funded renovations that move a home up at least 2 energy-rating bands.
A €2.5bn bullshit.