💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

Crowdfunding Platform Award

Competition was fierce among crowdfunding platforms. Not only have small-business defaults exploded, but France has the peculiarity of a very large share of property lending on these platforms. And the market turn triggered a major crisis among property dealers, the people who buy, renovate and resell, even though the platforms kept explaining that if they borrowed at 12%, there was no particular risk!

But one player stood head and shoulders above the rest this year, once again: Bricks, obviously. Consistent in its bullshit, Cédric O’Neill’s company made a sharp turn after the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, forced it to drop its royalties model. The company even had to rework its corporate structure to avoid conflicts of interest and obtain its licence as a crowdfunding service provider under EU rules.

A fresh start, then?

Luckily for the Bullshit Awards: no.

After 6 months with no projects, Bricks launched two (borrowing at 7% when other platforms show double that) for €1.2M in Portugal (where a managing director had been appointed the year before), whose project owner is none other than... Cédric O’Neill’s brother. Fortunately, says the company, an expert investment committee has been set up to check that the deals are sound.

Phew.

At the end of 2023, the committee approved the “Appartement Voltaire” project, an Airbnb in the seaside town of La Ciotat refinanced at 7.5% with a displayed yield of... 33.5%, thanks to a project owner who multiplied his nightly rate by 365.

A month later, an investment in Paris displayed a 25.5% yield, then a second one 18.6%.

Thank goodness the year closed with a third investment in Lisbon by the brother, for under €600,000, through 3 empty shell companies with no accounts, for a mere 19% yield, or I might have doubted how serious the committee was.

Note: missing out by just a few weeks, Mazar escapes a nomination for its report that leaves out the defaults.
Note 2: I’ll soon come back to the sector’s real figures, especially late payments and defaults.