For a €1,000 Roubaix note, the final transfer, the one on Friday 30 October, closes a 3-line breakdown that ClubFunding sets out for Zero Bullshit: the €270.29 of capital already returned, the net coupons received since 2022, around €300, and the balance paid that day, €530 on average, between €466 and €575: the less tax a bondholder's coupons bore, the higher the balance. The interest was supposed to come on top of the €1,000 repaid at maturity. In the final deal, it serves to make up the €1,000: €270.29 and €530 make about €800 of capital returned, and 4 years of coupons fill the gap to reach €1,100. On each note, the group therefore keeps €200 of the capital lent, 20%, and the coupons meant to pay for the loan serve to repay it. Instead of the €1,200 promised over 2 years, the bondholder gets back €1,100 over 4 years.
A €1,000 “Mille Cheminées” note, from the promise to the last transfer
Promised coupons gross, received coupons net of tax
On paper, €1,100 for €1,000 lent, or 10% over 4 years, roughly what a Livret A would have paid, the tax-free, state-regulated savings account every French saver has, risk-free and available at any time. The Livret A does not make its savers vote every few months. Adjusted for inflation (in French), it is a loss.
Depending on the collateral of their issue, each bondholder gets back in total, coupons included, “the equivalent of 100% or 110% of their initial capital”, plus a compensation payment of about twenty euros per bond, ClubFunding explains. Roubaix belongs to the Groupe SGM issues, whose security gave “more levers”, according to the platform. Those of SIGM Investissements, another group company, are settled at 100% including gross coupons: the private investors financed the group there for 4 years for a gross return of zero, compensation aside, and the coupons that reassured them are clawed back in the breakdown. ClubFunding draws the conclusion itself:
“The capital returned is still lower than the capital invested.”
The platform says this loss will appear in its statistics.
Promised: €1,200, then nearly €1,490 after the amendments. Received: €1,100. On Merlin's side, the bill is much gentler. The group promised 10%, then up to 15%. It paid about 5% a year for Roubaix, and nothing at all for SIGM Investissements: 4 years of free money, advanced by retail investors.
In 2022, the 10% made people want to lend. In 2026, the same coupons make it possible to announce that the bondholders got their money back.