💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 11

Keep calm and carry on

Since 2011, Lagardère’s core shareholder has been the Qatar Investment Authority (QIA), Qatar’s sovereign wealth fund, which manages between 500 and $550bn. At the end of 2019, QIA20 rises to 13% of the capital and 19% of the voting rights. At the time, Lagardère holds 7.33%, and Amber Capital, an activist investment fund, completes the podium with 6.73%.

QIA’s presence is no accident. Its manager, Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani, Emir of Qatar since 2013, is close to Jean-Luc Lagardère, but also to Nicolas Sarkozy. In fact, it was long whispered that Sarkozy and Arnaud were involved in the purchase of the PSG football club by QSI, Qatar Sports Investments.

If QIA shows patience with Lagardère, Amber Capital does not. Also in since 2011, the fund run by Joseph Oughourlian (owner and chairman of the RC Lens football club since 2019) books a gain by selling out in 2013. But after the share price slump in 2016, Amber returns with around 5% of the capital and demands a withdrawal from sport and media to refocus on publishing and airport shops, a strategy partly followed, as we saw earlier.

And Oughourlian is no ordinary activist. In 2014, he forces out Frédéric Vincent from the cable maker Nexans. The following year, he buys into the Spanish media group Prisa, which he forces to sell its stake in Le Monde, before helping Vivendi in a raid on the Guillemot brothers (Gameloft / Ubisoft).

A few days before the takeover bid closes, Amber tenders 15% of the shares to Vivendi21, allowing Bolloré to take control of Gameloft. A similar operation had taken place when the Activision shares were sold in 2013.

In 2018, Amber demands a seat on the supervisory board and criticises excessive pay, financial opacity and the role of Lagardère Capital & Management (LCM), Arnaud’s holding company where his shares sit, which has never published its accounts.

At first, QIA backs Amber. Furious, Arnaud sends in Pierre Leroy, a loyal adviser to his father, to turn things around. Leroy calls on Nasser Al-Khelaïfi (boss of PSG and QSI) and Nicolas Sarkozy. Five days later, QIA changes its position and saves Arnaud’s neck.

The final deal is negotiated by another adviser, Ramzi Khiroun, a spin doctor wearing many hats. He came to Lagardère via the Racing Club de France in 2006, grew close to DSK (Dominique Strauss-Kahn) around 2007, then joined Arnaud in 2010 for the EADS affair. He is also the man who handled Richard Gasquet’s communications after his positive test for cocaine. At the time, Khiroun even had a company Porsche provided by Lagardère, at the heart of a media score-settling between Sarkozy’s and DSK’s supporters.22

After the Sofitel affair, the 2011 New York hotel scandal that sank DSK, he drifts away from DSK and closer to Arnaud, despite strong internal resistance… which he eventually makes disappear.23

That deal is the appointment to the board of Jamal Benomar24, a Moroccan diplomat and former UN assistant secretary-general, supposedly independent, who was in fact close to Qatar. Khiroun had met Benomar in London a few months earlier through one of the Emir’s brothers. The deal earns Khiroun a €1.7M bonus for his, ahem, bravery.

A tug of war follows and spills into the media. Word goes round that the holding company is very heavily in debt, far beyond the value of the shares, which keep falling.

Amber wins a court order for the holding company’s accounts to be published. But Arnaud refuses, and would rather pay a fine of €2,000 a day than reveal the documents.

But why all the secrecy?