💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 08

Mini-Me

Very quickly, Arnaud is challenged across the various branches of his companies. An executive of the time explains:

Arnaud, he says, was always seen as an upstart. He ended up at the head of the group by accident, while some people already saw themselves with a bit more power than he was going to leave them. Add the fact that he wasn’t ready, and often gave the impression he didn’t really want the job, and he was beaten before he started.

The question of whether Arnaud really wanted to run the group keeps coming up among those close to Lagardère. Hard to say whether everyone is projecting their own fantasies or whether the question is genuinely well founded.

Jean-Luc was a respected, sometimes feared figure, whom the media, including his own, described in glowing terms. Arnaud, on the other hand, never enjoyed such indulgence.

In 2006, the news weekly Le Nouvel Observateur runs the headline “Lagardère : où va Arnaud ?” [Lagardère: where is Arnaud heading?]. The article describes dithering, contradictory announcements, an indecipherable strategy and difficulty making decisions. A few weeks later, the Clearstream affair finishes splitting the group apart.

The famous “Lagardère Boys”, led by Jean-Louis Gergorin, Jean-Paul Gut, Philippe Camus, Fabrice Brégier and Noël Forgeard, engage in slanderous denunciations, publicly destabilising EADS. Arnaud, meanwhile, stays silent

At the time, Alcatel is finalising its merger with Lucent and looking to offload Thales. Lagardère has been in the running since 2004, but for lack of a clear position from EADS, it’s Dassault that wins in the end.

Instead of buying Thales, Lagardère above all parted ways with EADS. Between November 2005 and March 2006, many Airbus and EADS executives exercise their stock options. Many of these trades raise questions, coming just before major announcements.

The most striking episode comes in June 2006, when the announcement of the A380’s delay sends the share price crashing: -36%. But back in March 2006, several executives had made impressive gains:

  • Forgeard, executive chairman of EADS, buys and sells 162,000 shares for a gain of €2.5M, plus €4.2M for his children.
  • Auque, head of EADS Space: 10,000 shares, +€114,000.
  • Gut, managing director of EADS: 50,000 shares, +€737,000.
  • Itavuori, HR director of EADS: 95,000 shares, +€1.2M.
  • Andriès, VP of Airbus: 56,000 shares, +€389,000.
  • Leahy, former sales director of Airbus: 260,000 shares, +€3.12M.
  • Pillet, former HR director of Airbus: 50,000 shares, +€540,000.
  • Humbert, former CEO of Airbus: 160,000 shares, +€1.685M.
  • Enders, former executive chairman of EADS: 50,000 shares, +€712,000.

Also named: Thierry Breton (Finance Minister), Francis Mayer (head of the Caisse des Dépôts, the French state’s financial arm), his successor Augustin de Romanet, and Xavier Musca (head of the Treasury). And of course Arnaud Lagardère, who sells the group’s 7.5% of EADS on 4 April 2006 for €2bn.

Forgeard, Gut, Humbert and Sperl are placed under formal investigation. The AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, closes its case without sanctions. In the end, none of the nine people targeted by the courts will stand trial, because of a procedural hitch linked to the AMF closing its investigation.

Forgeard eventually resigns, pocketing several million euros in severance along the way, and making the golden parachute a household term in the French media.14